1
00:00:07,62 --> 00:00:11,77
Good evening and welcome to the January
twenty first two thousand and fifteen town

2
00:00:11,78 --> 00:00:16,04
board meeting I'll officially call the
meeting to order and I'll ask that you

3
00:00:16,05 --> 00:00:22,75
please rise for the pledge.
Of. Allegiance to the

4
00:00:23,73 --> 00:00:30,37
you know States of America and Europe all
that really stands one nation I know this

5
00:00:30,38 --> 00:00:30,50
is

6
00:00:31,04 --> 00:00:37,59
a very just. Thank you. All I ask
our clerk to please call the roll

7
00:00:38,28 --> 00:00:44,66
call. Here that's like here more
here click here OK thank you

8
00:00:45,24 --> 00:00:52,18
we have two public hearing this evening
and I'll ask our clerk to please read

9
00:00:52,42 --> 00:00:58,76
the first item to consider the establishment
of the Ashton Rice subdivision special

10
00:00:59,04 --> 00:01:03,91
movement district legal notice was published
in the Penfield post on January eighth

11
00:01:03,92 --> 00:01:09,65
two thousand and fifteen and posted on the
town website and the town bulletin board

12
00:01:10,15 --> 00:01:15,03
eighty two post cards were mailed and three
homeowners associations were notified

13
00:01:15,76 --> 00:01:20,59
OK Thank you Mr Horowitz is this properly
before the border city right I'd like to

14
00:01:20,76 --> 00:01:25,76
recognize our Director of Development
Developmental Services Jim Costello to give

15
00:01:25,77 --> 00:01:32,71
us an overview of this matter to. Order
and this is stacked up this is kind

16
00:01:32,72 --> 00:01:36,76
of an unusual circumstance for us generally
when districts are formed they're

17
00:01:36,77 --> 00:01:42,30
formed prior to any development taking place
and within the subdivision this is an

18
00:01:42,31 --> 00:01:46,55
unusual circumstance of the town board
recognizing that because of the right reason

19
00:01:46,56 --> 00:01:52,04
and as for regulations stormwater
regulations in the situation where each new

20
00:01:52,05 --> 00:01:56,43
development has to have its own pond for
storm water quality and quantity purposes

21
00:01:57,43 --> 00:02:01,23
the town was in the process of determining
how the best way to handle this was

22
00:02:01,24 --> 00:02:06,18
occurring at the time that the national
right subdivision was approved in

23
00:02:06,25 --> 00:02:08,65
ultimately under construction so as

24
00:02:08,66 --> 00:02:12,17
a result construction was occurring as we
were making our decisions regarding the

25
00:02:12,18 --> 00:02:16,76
creation of special improvement districts
which the board did do by that time we

26
00:02:16,77 --> 00:02:20,53
realized that we now had to go back to the
property owners who actually had been

27
00:02:20,54 --> 00:02:23,60
building and living within the subdivision
to make them aware of the fact that

28
00:02:23,61 --> 00:02:27,61
there was this issue explain that to
them and then let them know what the

29
00:02:27,62 --> 00:02:32,81
repercussions would be in the event that
the district was not created or if one was

30
00:02:32,81 --> 00:02:34,14
. We did receive

31
00:02:34,15 --> 00:02:38,38
a petition it was signed by almost everybody
I will tell you that it was not signed

32
00:02:38,39 --> 00:02:43,56
by everybody there were one or two
property owners the did not sign and Brian

33
00:02:43,57 --> 00:02:46,59
Holmes was one of the property owners that
on the majority the property the time

34
00:02:46,60 --> 00:02:50,09
they obviously did sign. So as

35
00:02:50,10 --> 00:02:54,80
a result what occurred was. The developers
representative and I did go to the

36
00:02:54,81 --> 00:02:58,68
majority of homes and talk to each of the
property owners about what was going to

37
00:02:58,69 --> 00:03:03,91
happen if they did not sign in really with
what happens in this case because of two

38
00:03:03,92 --> 00:03:05,21
issues in the subdivision they have

39
00:03:05,22 --> 00:03:08,80
a sign that identifies the name of
the subdivision and they also have

40
00:03:08,81 --> 00:03:13,44
a pond that has to be maintained which
is currently being maintained by the

41
00:03:13,45 --> 00:03:16,88
developer and that will occur until
such time as the developments will be

42
00:03:16,89 --> 00:03:20,69
constructed in which case the developer
will then dedicate that lane to the town of

43
00:03:20,70 --> 00:03:25,03
Penfield and will then we
will be responsible through

44
00:03:25,04 --> 00:03:30,15
a taxing program to mow the grass around
the pond and maintain it to the properties

45
00:03:30,24 --> 00:03:36,36
owners and subdivisions determination
we have done some calculations we have

46
00:03:36,37 --> 00:03:38,37
determined that it's

47
00:03:38,38 --> 00:03:42,35
a lot of depending upon up with the OEM
homeowners want for that subdivision if

48
00:03:42,36 --> 00:03:47,72
they want good maiden's where it's manicured
as it is at this point time or will be

49
00:03:48,40 --> 00:03:52,64
once the weather breaks again
our director of the D.P.W.

50
00:03:52,65 --> 00:03:56,61
Had indicated to me today that
he's charged he is charged by

51
00:03:56,62 --> 00:04:02,31
a contractor sixty dollars per cut on the
on these times throughout the community

52
00:04:02,84 --> 00:04:07,79
so if the developers. The developers are
going to maintain this for the next year

53
00:04:07,80 --> 00:04:08,69
or so that should not be

54
00:04:08,70 --> 00:04:12,50
a problem for the for the property owners
the property owners have the opportunity

55
00:04:12,51 --> 00:04:16,11
to determine whether or not they want it
manicured or if they want to be less of

56
00:04:16,12 --> 00:04:17,80
manicured or even go back to

57
00:04:17,81 --> 00:04:21,77
a wild state it is at the entrance to
their subdivision so I'm suspecting that

58
00:04:21,78 --> 00:04:25,06
they're not going to want to see
that happen if it's manicured to

59
00:04:25,07 --> 00:04:29,91
a point where it's mode. Every Other Week
throughout the summer months at sixty

60
00:04:29,92 --> 00:04:35,12
dollars times twelve you get seven hundred
twenty dollars for the summer and the

61
00:04:35,13 --> 00:04:41,10
fall. That divided by the thirty six property
owners within the track. Would bring

62
00:04:41,11 --> 00:04:41,68
that down to

63
00:04:41,69 --> 00:04:48,52
a point where they would be around. I don't
know I was just going to sign as well

64
00:04:48,53 --> 00:04:53,67
we're charging two dollars per year per
property for the same maintenance the

65
00:04:53,68 --> 00:04:57,87
purpose of that is to ensure that ten years
from now or fifteen years from now when

66
00:04:57,88 --> 00:04:58,64
the saying goes into

67
00:04:58,65 --> 00:05:02,91
a state of disrepair rather than one of the
property owners having to go into each

68
00:05:02,92 --> 00:05:07,16
home and ask each of each property owner
for some money to repair that sign they're

69
00:05:07,17 --> 00:05:11,24
not going to be required to do that we will
take care of that for them at the point

70
00:05:11,25 --> 00:05:15,17
that it needs to be repaired if something
happens to the science to an accident or

71
00:05:15,18 --> 00:05:16,35
somebody hits the sign with

72
00:05:16,36 --> 00:05:20,82
a vehicle or something of that nature the
town and the property owners will not be

73
00:05:20,83 --> 00:05:24,11
really responsible for the payment that
would come through the sureness companies

74
00:05:24,12 --> 00:05:28,35
as has happened in the town in the
past so it's mainly it's mainly

75
00:05:28,36 --> 00:05:32,95
a repainting standing that kind of issue
for the sign if we charge two dollars per

76
00:05:32,96 --> 00:05:35,88
year it comes out to seventy
two dollars per year over

77
00:05:35,89 --> 00:05:39,77
a ten year period we kind of get close to
the cost of that sign and I'm going to

78
00:05:39,78 --> 00:05:44,42
supporting that same will be in good shape
ten or fifteen years from now if you add

79
00:05:44,43 --> 00:05:50,76
those two fees together it would come out
to seven hundred sixty fifty six dollars

80
00:05:50,77 --> 00:05:54,91
per year for the entire subdivision
divided by thirty six would be twenty one

81
00:05:54,92 --> 00:05:59,18
dollars per year per family within the
subdivision for the maintenance of the pond

82
00:05:59,84 --> 00:06:05,15
and the sign if the developers I'm sorry
if the property owners decide they'd like

83
00:06:05,16 --> 00:06:09,66
to have less than twelve cuts per year
on their pond. It could come down

84
00:06:09,67 --> 00:06:14,09
drastically depending on what they do
determine to be an appropriate number. And we

85
00:06:14,10 --> 00:06:16,77
would have to sit down with them to determine
if they're comparable with the twelve

86
00:06:16,78 --> 00:06:21,14
cuts or if they'd like less than that or
more than that depending on the situation

87
00:06:21,14 --> 00:06:26,92
. That's kind of where we are I did for
those who are here for the for the

88
00:06:26,93 --> 00:06:32,15
subdivision I did bring a brochure for
you to take home with you that addresses

89
00:06:32,27 --> 00:06:35,61
a special treatment the structure more than
welcome to take some home if you'd like

90
00:06:35,62 --> 00:06:39,37
to get to your neighbors who are not here
tonight that's going to be my question

91
00:06:39,38 --> 00:06:43,81
Jim is for property owners there what
what do they do from here on out you know

92
00:06:43,82 --> 00:06:49,48
assuming that this goes into effect you
know I'm kind of happy I see the sign is

93
00:06:49,52 --> 00:06:55,48
getting chipped peeled deteriorating but
what if what we do then this sign will be

94
00:06:55,49 --> 00:06:59,21
maintained by the developers until such
time as they leave the site that probably

95
00:06:59,22 --> 00:07:03,02
would be another yourself if something
happens during that period of time they let

96
00:07:03,03 --> 00:07:06,62
us know that's an issue we will contact
the developer ensure that they have that

97
00:07:06,63 --> 00:07:08,23
repaired before they
leave the site we have

98
00:07:08,24 --> 00:07:13,23
a lot of credit to ensure that occurs
before they leave after that period of time

99
00:07:13,24 --> 00:07:15,52
if something happens where the
sign does start to come into

100
00:07:15,53 --> 00:07:19,49
a state of disrepair and used to be repainted
we would have to sign taken care of

101
00:07:19,50 --> 00:07:20,90
through a contractor through

102
00:07:20,91 --> 00:07:25,04
a low bid process that we're going to repair
the sign and then that money will come

103
00:07:25,05 --> 00:07:30,00
out of the the fees that have been collected
for the meanings of the sign so it's

104
00:07:30,01 --> 00:07:30,35
merely

105
00:07:30,36 --> 00:07:35,40
a one of the property owners contacting
the town that's right now tonight we're

106
00:07:35,46 --> 00:07:37,32
we're here is a public hearing
we're not here to make

107
00:07:37,33 --> 00:07:41,60
a decision I disappointed that what would
happen after this public hearing is that

108
00:07:41,61 --> 00:07:44,98
we will meet with the neighbors or group
of the neighbors who represent the entire

109
00:07:44,99 --> 00:07:46,51
subdivision get

110
00:07:46,52 --> 00:07:49,62
a feeling for them as to what they're
confortable with with the number of cuts per

111
00:07:49,63 --> 00:07:53,67
year for the for the pond area and then
bring that back to you and the town

112
00:07:53,68 --> 00:07:57,97
assessor so that they have you all have
an idea of what it is they're looking for

113
00:07:57,98 --> 00:08:04,92
in terms of an annual maintenance
program for that area. Board

114
00:08:05,04 --> 00:08:11,24
their questions or comments from Mr
Constable before we open. It up to the just

115
00:08:11,33 --> 00:08:15,87
just one question maybe
clarification. Response or mention

116
00:08:15,88 --> 00:08:20,15
a sign of falls in disrepair but what about
landscaping or embellish it's what is

117
00:08:20,16 --> 00:08:22,92
the extent of special and
special problem that's

118
00:08:22,93 --> 00:08:27,43
a very good question because the other side
of that is if the developers leave the

119
00:08:27,44 --> 00:08:32,20
site as it's currently situated and the
property owners get together and decide

120
00:08:32,21 --> 00:08:36,52
they would like to see it special improvements
additional landscaping perhaps or if

121
00:08:36,53 --> 00:08:37,43
they want to see

122
00:08:38,31 --> 00:08:42,17
a narration system installed in the pond
area something of that nature do you know

123
00:08:42,18 --> 00:08:46,21
cut down on algae growth they have every
right to come to the town and ask for that

124
00:08:46,98 --> 00:08:50,18
we would certainly go out and get prices
in quotes for them you know we are

125
00:08:50,19 --> 00:08:54,04
policies always get at least three quotes
we would sit down with them and indicate

126
00:08:54,05 --> 00:08:57,69
this is what it would cost we would have
to assess that to the special improvement

127
00:08:57,70 --> 00:08:58,26
district over

128
00:08:58,27 --> 00:09:02,73
a period of time but they could actually
ask for betterments if they'd like to.

129
00:09:04,03 --> 00:09:07,85
Versus just keeping it minimal it's going
to be up to the neighborhood to do what

130
00:09:07,86 --> 00:09:11,58
they like to do for the for the you
know for the site we will act as

131
00:09:11,59 --> 00:09:15,79
a liaison for them and the contractors to
get that work done recognizing that they

132
00:09:15,80 --> 00:09:20,40
would pay for that through the special
Improvement District fees so the cost of

133
00:09:20,41 --> 00:09:24,00
a borne by the homeowners it always will
be few and that was the whole purpose of

134
00:09:24,01 --> 00:09:28,38
our long discussion regarding homeowners
association versus special improvement

135
00:09:28,39 --> 00:09:32,25
districts you can trust the homeowners
association in single family detached

136
00:09:32,26 --> 00:09:35,39
housing because nobody wants to be that
person not going to everybody's door to say

137
00:09:35,40 --> 00:09:40,15
I want I really need this much money from
you this year to affect improvements now

138
00:09:40,16 --> 00:09:43,20
it's just tax their tax
program to get it done on

139
00:09:43,21 --> 00:09:47,24
a day basis and they don't have to go out
and ask her neighbors for more money it's

140
00:09:47,25 --> 00:09:51,85
going to be dependent upon what they really
want in terms of betterments or keeping

141
00:09:51,86 --> 00:09:52,16
it at

142
00:09:52,17 --> 00:09:57,05
a minimal maintenance program they have
the right to do either one. I just did

143
00:09:57,06 --> 00:09:59,09
a new deal for example if we take

144
00:09:59,10 --> 00:10:04,84
a look at very broad pond that we have
there and you know like avenue we do not

145
00:10:04,85 --> 00:10:09,88
mold that pond the way it was you know set
up and design. There are some cat tails

146
00:10:10,05 --> 00:10:14,64
there are some wildflowers and there is
essentially no more we made and some of

147
00:10:14,65 --> 00:10:21,11
that that pond it all so that's one that's
one extreme that guy but the other one

148
00:10:21,12 --> 00:10:25,73
would be as Mr Costello had indicated if
you want to keep it warm manicured it

149
00:10:25,74 --> 00:10:31,40
could be you know as many as ten or twelve
times or if you wanted to go middle of

150
00:10:31,41 --> 00:10:37,67
the road and do it two or three times so
I mean it really is part of this part of

151
00:10:37,68 --> 00:10:42,54
this discussion will be to see what the
appetite for the you know property owners

152
00:10:42,55 --> 00:10:47,51
are as to what to what degree they want
to keep keep that kept when you bring up

153
00:10:47,52 --> 00:10:51,31
a good point because the other end of this
is if the district was not created there

154
00:10:51,32 --> 00:10:53,53
be no maintenance on our part
it would just go back to

155
00:10:53,54 --> 00:10:58,50
a state of you know natural development
as to what it was we would not spend the

156
00:10:58,51 --> 00:11:03,83
time or the money on the pond to maintain
it or manicure it. But we would make sure

157
00:11:03,84 --> 00:11:05,22
that it functions properly and that's

158
00:11:05,23 --> 00:11:08,52
a different issue and everybody in the
town of Penfield as you know pays

159
00:11:08,53 --> 00:11:14,16
a drainage tax fee we're all responsible
for that the actual maintenance of the you

160
00:11:14,17 --> 00:11:17,70
know princes of the pond had to be dragged
at some point in time or if the pipe

161
00:11:17,71 --> 00:11:21,61
system had to be improved at some point in
time that does come out of the drainage

162
00:11:21,62 --> 00:11:25,80
fees that we all pay as resident time
Penfield and they're not responsible for that

163
00:11:25,81 --> 00:11:30,25
kind of improvement through the special
district that is something that we all take

164
00:11:30,26 --> 00:11:35,70
care of our dreams program. You know Jim
regarding the the entranceway with the

165
00:11:35,71 --> 00:11:40,84
sign and the neighborhood is certainly
free to get together they'd like to say

166
00:11:40,85 --> 00:11:44,12
deployment flowers landscaping
maybe that if they have

167
00:11:44,13 --> 00:11:49,50
a garden club that gets formed and they
want to embellish it and their own and they

168
00:11:49,51 --> 00:11:53,85
really do know because the sign is actually
on private property we have an access

169
00:11:53,86 --> 00:11:57,49
easement to it too if we have to take it
off the property because it's it's not

170
00:11:57,50 --> 00:12:01,26
being maintained or if we have to repair
it we have access to it to make sure that

171
00:12:01,27 --> 00:12:05,28
we can do that but in essence it's on
private property and you know the neighbors

172
00:12:05,29 --> 00:12:09,15
cannot go into one one neighbor's property
and do things without my permission. Of

173
00:12:09,16 --> 00:12:13,82
the present property owner That's correct.
And I know that the property owner that

174
00:12:13,83 --> 00:12:14,02
has

175
00:12:14,03 --> 00:12:20,99
a sign on his property is actually
in attendance one so I please. So

176
00:12:21,00 --> 00:12:27,88
other other companies that were.
Questions. OK so let's open it

177
00:12:27,89 --> 00:12:33,63
up to the audience at this point. Has anyone
signed up to speak for this particular

178
00:12:33,64 --> 00:12:38,64
public hearing if you didn't that's OK Jim
Well next go to those that did not sign

179
00:12:38,65 --> 00:12:43,50
up but would like to to address this matter.
You don't have anybody for the public

180
00:12:43,51 --> 00:12:48,24
here OK great so any one of the audience
that would like to address this matter yes

181
00:12:48,25 --> 00:12:52,72
sir please please come up and
give us your name and address.

182
00:12:57,92 --> 00:13:02,76
I much Ed Miller I I own the property
at ten actually rise which contains the

183
00:13:02,77 --> 00:13:08,70
monument so yes indeed it is on private
property. Up to this point the.

184
00:13:09,78 --> 00:13:15,78
Developer and we are in has
maintained the sign and actually has

185
00:13:16,67 --> 00:13:21,91
improved I guess that's the right word
improve the. Land around the sign for

186
00:13:21,92 --> 00:13:26,08
a distance of about. Thirty feet on

187
00:13:26,09 --> 00:13:29,34
a side with some low shrubs and also with

188
00:13:29,35 --> 00:13:35,90
a very interesting solar panel operated
lighting scheme which is interesting. I

189
00:13:35,91 --> 00:13:42,31
don't have any difficulty with another
property owner asking permission to go

190
00:13:42,98 --> 00:13:49,11
on to the land occupied by the monument and
embellishing it with with the printing

191
00:13:49,12 --> 00:13:54,74
L's but more annual But I do have an issue
with the treatment plant being planted

192
00:13:54,75 --> 00:13:57,47
by somebody saw Bill would
certainly be interested in having

193
00:13:58,03 --> 00:14:02,04
a discussion with that if there
arises a group of people that form

194
00:14:02,05 --> 00:14:04,65
a little garden club or something like that
want to do something then we could all

195
00:14:04,66 --> 00:14:04,78
have

196
00:14:04,79 --> 00:14:09,94
a discussion but right now I would I would
want input into. Anything that's attempted

197
00:14:10,90 --> 00:14:12,41
I don't anticipate that will happen for

198
00:14:12,42 --> 00:14:17,35
a while the developer still in control of
everything. So there is there's really no

199
00:14:17,36 --> 00:14:23,10
current issue with any access requests or
anything so. Great if you think THANK YOU

200
00:14:23,89 --> 00:14:30,14
THANK YOU. So anyone else that would
like to address the Ashland rise special

201
00:14:30,15 --> 00:14:31,41
Improvement District.

202
00:14:37,14 --> 00:14:42,93
Representative. Because I don't like
knowing this is because until we're two

203
00:14:42,94 --> 00:14:47,16
adjacent neighbors while we might not be
we came here because we're having some

204
00:14:47,20 --> 00:14:50,31
other issues and this is not the
place I would not be this is not

205
00:14:50,32 --> 00:14:54,48
a place to do it but there is an opportunity
if you'd like to address the board

206
00:14:54,49 --> 00:14:54,83
this is

207
00:14:54,84 --> 00:14:59,37
a public hearing specifically on the
improvement district if you have other issues

208
00:14:59,38 --> 00:15:04,29
that you'd like to talk to the board
about. We will address that public

209
00:15:04,30 --> 00:15:10,51
participation in about twenty minutes or
thereabouts plus or minus depending upon

210
00:15:10,52 --> 00:15:14,18
how this public how long this public hearing
goes in the next public hearing goes

211
00:15:14,53 --> 00:15:19,72
OK so if you'd like to sit back and
relax and enjoy and then you'll have an

212
00:15:19,73 --> 00:15:26,17
opportunity to about fifteen or twenty
minutes. All right thank you. So

213
00:15:26,55 --> 00:15:33,21
yes ma'am please come
forward. I am Shannon

214
00:15:33,22 --> 00:15:37,64
Williams I'm an eleven national rounds
I'm one of the individuals that didn't

215
00:15:38,07 --> 00:15:44,82
initially sign off on any of the petitions
that went around I do have some

216
00:15:44,83 --> 00:15:51,55
concerns. There's the pond seems
to have attracted about thirty

217
00:15:51,65 --> 00:15:56,93
geese that wander around the neighborhood
they're all over the sidewalks there in

218
00:15:56,94 --> 00:16:03,37
the street there in the yards. I am
concerned you mentioned if there were if we

219
00:16:03,38 --> 00:16:08,62
wanted to ration put in things like that
that would be something that we would have

220
00:16:08,63 --> 00:16:13,19
to come. Address after the fact but is there
anything that would be done beforehand

221
00:16:13,69 --> 00:16:14,50
knowing that this is

222
00:16:14,51 --> 00:16:21,51
a preexisting problem with the
geese. I did I know you're

223
00:16:21,52 --> 00:16:24,24
absolutely right if you talk to several
neighbors and I actually witnessed to

224
00:16:24,25 --> 00:16:27,86
myself the pond has attracted
several geese I know you have

225
00:16:27,87 --> 00:16:33,31
a problem down the street and around the
pond and that's why I'm talking to the

226
00:16:33,32 --> 00:16:33,91
D.P.W.

227
00:16:33,92 --> 00:16:38,98
Director and he recognizes that as well we
found in other parts of the town. We've

228
00:16:38,99 --> 00:16:42,95
had problems in other parts of the town and
we found that once cattle world starts

229
00:16:42,96 --> 00:16:46,83
growing up around the pond area where
they can't get access to it they have

230
00:16:46,84 --> 00:16:50,73
a tendency not to stay there for after
a period of time that could be quite

231
00:16:50,74 --> 00:16:52,60
a while yet for you though and I know it's

232
00:16:52,61 --> 00:16:55,59
a problem theoretically
if you were to allow

233
00:16:55,60 --> 00:16:58,97
a certain area to grow between the street
and the pond every where they couldn't

234
00:16:58,98 --> 00:17:02,43
get access to the pond from the
street area it might deter them

235
00:17:02,44 --> 00:17:05,86
a little bit from actually going to the
pond or being in the area where the street

236
00:17:05,87 --> 00:17:11,53
is way right of the problems occurring
so I do appreciate the situation I have

237
00:17:11,54 --> 00:17:12,24
actually talked to

238
00:17:12,25 --> 00:17:15,25
a couple of neighbors who were concerned
about it as well I've actually put them in

239
00:17:15,26 --> 00:17:17,60
contact with the E.C. The E.C.

240
00:17:17,61 --> 00:17:22,13
Has certain protocols that they use I don't
know how effective they are but they do

241
00:17:22,14 --> 00:17:27,60
have protocols to try and minimize the
impact to the neighborhood so we could work

242
00:17:27,61 --> 00:17:31,14
with you in that regard to see if
that works if not we could look at

243
00:17:31,15 --> 00:17:32,59
a possibility of maybe leaving

244
00:17:32,60 --> 00:17:36,32
a strip of area around the edge of the pond
where they can't get access to it from

245
00:17:36,33 --> 00:17:40,39
the street then we deter them from staying
in the areas of their room. And that

246
00:17:40,40 --> 00:17:46,67
would be something that you could do. Build.
Into that I mean this program exactly

247
00:17:46,85 --> 00:17:48,87
and I think as I said we
need to sit down with you as

248
00:17:48,88 --> 00:17:52,13
a group and determine what your needs
really are and what you want to see happen

249
00:17:52,14 --> 00:17:56,53
down there but that might be one way to
deter them from if they can't get to the

250
00:17:56,61 --> 00:18:00,87
time from the street they might not stay
in the street area please go into the pond

251
00:18:00,88 --> 00:18:04,79
lights. I was just going to
quickly mention that we also have

252
00:18:04,80 --> 00:18:10,19
a pamphlet on living your stormwater. And
maybe. Jim could provide you with one of

253
00:18:10,20 --> 00:18:14,41
those and one of the most knowledgeable
men in the room is Jeff Benway he's back

254
00:18:14,42 --> 00:18:16,59
there and he every year in April does

255
00:18:16,60 --> 00:18:23,15
a wonderful series or lecture here on
storm living your storm one storm want to

256
00:18:23,16 --> 00:18:27,55
pines and I'm sure before he was sorry
before you leave now you may want to just

257
00:18:27,56 --> 00:18:31,47
chat with Jeff will probably give you some
other tips or at least some other ideas

258
00:18:31,79 --> 00:18:38,00
OK neighborhood thank you believe that
timeline as well as Jeff. Living on your

259
00:18:38,01 --> 00:18:44,91
lines. Our website yeah OK I did
also have another question and this

260
00:18:44,92 --> 00:18:51,66
is because of my ignorance but
I am curious what is if we do

261
00:18:51,91 --> 00:18:56,51
take on the special we and I it's my
understanding that we are requesting this

262
00:18:56,61 --> 00:19:02,26
special Improvement District. If something
happens in the pond if someone falls and

263
00:19:02,27 --> 00:19:03,36
is injured is there

264
00:19:03,37 --> 00:19:09,71
a liability that the property owners
shoulder. I'm going to look to our child

265
00:19:09,72 --> 00:19:10,89
attorney less.

266
00:19:16,49 --> 00:19:20,97
Like what could I do what would
that be speculate OK to plead

267
00:19:20,98 --> 00:19:25,69
a special improvement just your cases on
liability insurance and it would cover

268
00:19:25,70 --> 00:19:30,26
those kinds of situations OK
OK but the part that you make

269
00:19:30,27 --> 00:19:36,98
a conscious or not be my view is. It's
just I mean and that's very. True.

270
00:19:38,04 --> 00:19:42,40
Thank you thanks thank you the best way
to put I guess Jim is that this is the

271
00:19:42,41 --> 00:19:47,12
aperture this is the way we have property
owners way and what they'd like and

272
00:19:47,13 --> 00:19:47,55
certainly be

273
00:19:47,56 --> 00:19:51,76
a part of the process and coming for you
not only requesting it but you know

274
00:19:51,77 --> 00:19:57,31
seeking after the fact seeking various
proposals or you know to involve you in the

275
00:19:57,32 --> 00:20:02,60
process of maintaining the property
near you even though it as Jim says is

276
00:20:02,61 --> 00:20:09,55
dedicated to time and that the
patent itself. So anyone else would

277
00:20:09,56 --> 00:20:15,00
like to address the board on this matter
the special proven distributor for action

278
00:20:15,01 --> 00:20:21,94
on rice. OK board. Any further questions

279
00:20:22,06 --> 00:20:27,36
from Mr Costello on this site just one
quick question is just for Pfizer Jim I

280
00:20:27,37 --> 00:20:32,02
correct when I say that these types of
were tension patterns and new developments

281
00:20:32,06 --> 00:20:35,77
are a requirement for New
York State it's actually

282
00:20:35,78 --> 00:20:38,05
a federal requirement
but New York State D.C.

283
00:20:38,06 --> 00:20:42,18
Administers it for the state of New York
and these plans are now the plans we all

284
00:20:42,19 --> 00:20:45,44
grew up with we just dig out of this
area and just let it sit there and with

285
00:20:45,48 --> 00:20:49,75
retention they're now designed to accommodate
store more quantity but they're also

286
00:20:49,76 --> 00:20:54,04
designed to accommodate Strong want to
quality so you have people poor areas within

287
00:20:54,05 --> 00:20:57,46
them with shallow pool areas you have certain
kinds of plantings that are installed

288
00:20:57,47 --> 00:21:04,24
now to take. Out nutrient you know some of
the phosphorus and other things that are

289
00:21:04,25 --> 00:21:08,74
going through the water column so it's not
it's not like the old days we just dug

290
00:21:08,75 --> 00:21:13,19
a hole and hope for the best I mean it's
more about scientific process now for each

291
00:21:13,20 --> 00:21:17,32
of these parts and they have to be maintained
so they're mandated basically they're

292
00:21:17,33 --> 00:21:21,62
mandated were mandated to maintain them to
the standards that the federal and state

293
00:21:21,63 --> 00:21:23,59
governments have put together to insure

294
00:21:23,60 --> 00:21:30,01
a storm want to quality to the various
want to thank you. Other questions for Mr

295
00:21:30,02 --> 00:21:36,69
Costello. OK so what next steps tonight
is the public hearing so the next steps

296
00:21:37,11 --> 00:21:43,29
is that this will be further discussion at
work sessions and sounds like there will

297
00:21:43,30 --> 00:21:47,83
be some additional discussion with the
neighborhood as well as Mr Costello had

298
00:21:47,84 --> 00:21:54,82
indicated that will we will keep that
posted on our website that agenda on

299
00:21:54,83 --> 00:22:00,84
our website and you'll have an
opportunity whenever that comes up for

300
00:22:00,85 --> 00:22:05,45
a work session that will be on the agenda
and again you can check the website of

301
00:22:05,46 --> 00:22:10,79
Penfield dot org for that to find out when
the next time the board will take it up

302
00:22:11,11 --> 00:22:16,05
the next the earliest opportunity will
be next Wednesday the twenty eighth of

303
00:22:16,19 --> 00:22:21,84
January certainly everyone is everyone
anyone is welcome to attend we meet in the

304
00:22:21,85 --> 00:22:26,34
back of the room but again I would just
encourage you to go to the website to check

305
00:22:26,35 --> 00:22:33,08
the agenda to see if in fact it's
listed item on the agenda Ok seen no

306
00:22:33,09 --> 00:22:37,64
further questions or comments from
the board then I'll declare this

307
00:22:37,73 --> 00:22:44,64
a public hearing close and I'll ask
our clerk to next read. The public

308
00:22:44,65 --> 00:22:46,05
hearing for all of you R.P.

309
00:22:46,05 --> 00:22:52,07
. To consider the adoption of the
proposed update to the local waterfront

310
00:22:52,08 --> 00:22:58,05
revitalization program how W R P legal
notice was published in the pantheon post

311
00:22:58,06 --> 00:23:03,84
and January. If two thousand and fifteen
posted on the Tao website click bottom

312
00:23:03,85 --> 00:23:08,44
board no postcards your
mail. Due to this being

313
00:23:08,45 --> 00:23:14,96
a town where the action great Mr Harwood
says is properly before the board and so I

314
00:23:14,97 --> 00:23:20,42
will again will recognize Mr Costello as
he's coming to the podium I'd also like to

315
00:23:20,58 --> 00:23:24,61
to recognize Kerry Iverson from the town
of Rhonda quite often they're planning

316
00:23:24,62 --> 00:23:31,59
department. Jim Carey and representatives
from the town of Webster meet on

317
00:23:31,60 --> 00:23:38,56
a very regular basis on and happen
for for some time and so with that

318
00:23:38,69 --> 00:23:43,33
Kerry thank you for being here to hear
the comments from the public hearing and

319
00:23:43,84 --> 00:23:48,82
self you would give us an overview Thank
you Mr Supervisor and before I do that I

320
00:23:48,83 --> 00:23:52,90
would like to think Kerry because since
he's been working for the town of

321
00:23:52,91 --> 00:23:57,76
Ironically he's moved mountains in terms
of moving forward to get the people that

322
00:23:57,77 --> 00:23:58,98
town to

323
00:23:58,99 --> 00:24:03,67
a point where it's now getting to completion
and will be adoptable hopefully within

324
00:24:03,68 --> 00:24:06,41
the here some point in time we are kind of

325
00:24:06,42 --> 00:24:11,27
a time crunch now because the grant period
is now coming to an end and we need to

326
00:24:11,28 --> 00:24:16,72
get these documents done in order to
fulfill the requirements of the the great

327
00:24:16,73 --> 00:24:20,74
requirements so just to give you some
background as to where we are and where we've

328
00:24:20,75 --> 00:24:26,46
been in town of Penfield did adopt its
original L W R P A local waterfront reply

329
00:24:26,47 --> 00:24:26,71
was

330
00:24:26,72 --> 00:24:31,81
a from program in July of one thousand
nine hundred one and shortly thereafter it

331
00:24:31,82 --> 00:24:37,98
was adopted and approved by the secretary
of state in October of that year through

332
00:24:37,99 --> 00:24:41,52
that period of time the
purpose of the L.W.R. P.

333
00:24:41,53 --> 00:24:43,58
Is to act as a partnership in

334
00:24:43,59 --> 00:24:48,40
a partnership of the state of New York
whereby the state sets out policies that the

335
00:24:48,41 --> 00:24:53,67
towns follow and in the purpose of following
the policy and maintaining consistency

336
00:24:53,68 --> 00:24:58,09
with what the state determines the be
appropriate for waterfront development and

337
00:24:58,34 --> 00:25:03,19
preservation of the environment. The
state then allows each town to apply for

338
00:25:03,20 --> 00:25:06,85
grants in the town of Penfield has actually
been the recipient of several grants

339
00:25:07,59 --> 00:25:11,80
most notably the grant that we received
purchased Zimmerman lands on the on the

340
00:25:11,81 --> 00:25:12,37
conflicts of

341
00:25:12,38 --> 00:25:17,95
a runaway Creek and the bay which is now
known as one thousand in park we also

342
00:25:17,96 --> 00:25:21,96
receive subsequent grants to allow for some
boardwalk development within that park

343
00:25:22,94 --> 00:25:27,24
and actually allowed for some acquisition
of other lands within the realm of the

344
00:25:27,25 --> 00:25:27,82
R.P.

345
00:25:27,83 --> 00:25:33,66
To revitalize the town's waterfront. On the
television screen you do see the existing

346
00:25:34,05 --> 00:25:40,66
existing boundaries of R L W R P. Shortly
after that boundary was created and

347
00:25:40,67 --> 00:25:46,31
approved it became apparent that it was
too excessive in terms of its scope and

348
00:25:46,32 --> 00:25:51,34
size the boundaries really fall on the
property line of the town of Western

349
00:25:51,35 --> 00:25:55,89
Penfield out to the center of the bay they
power through the center of the bay down

350
00:25:55,90 --> 00:25:59,46
to Brown probabl of art and follow
Brown probable of art up to create

351
00:25:59,68 --> 00:26:04,01
a creek street to follow Creek Street up
to Empire Boulevard and then take empire

352
00:26:04,02 --> 00:26:10,60
to Bay. And then tie into the town line
and Webster once we really realize that

353
00:26:10,61 --> 00:26:16,24
much of that land within the L W R P
was not really functional in terms of

354
00:26:16,25 --> 00:26:20,17
providing revitalization to the waterfront
we determine that it was probably had to

355
00:26:20,18 --> 00:26:24,76
be reduced in scope and as part of this
project that's what we're doing we're

356
00:26:24,77 --> 00:26:30,03
taking out many of the properties and
creeks treat some of the properties over

357
00:26:30,26 --> 00:26:37,25
often white village. Parks you drive
old Westfall those properties are

358
00:26:37,26 --> 00:26:40,61
obviously remote from
areas where we would do

359
00:26:40,62 --> 00:26:45,25
a lot of the work in terms of waterfront
realization we did keep the wetlands

360
00:26:45,26 --> 00:26:49,61
around those areas though because there's
an opportunity for hiking trails all

361
00:26:49,62 --> 00:26:50,58
sorts of you know maybe

362
00:26:50,59 --> 00:26:54,67
a little kayak launches that kind of thing
that we are eligible for funding and we

363
00:26:54,68 --> 00:26:57,54
didn't want to miss the opportunity of
being able to apply for those kinds of

364
00:26:57,55 --> 00:27:04,33
branches as time went on. The purpose
of the the update was actually

365
00:27:04,34 --> 00:27:09,40
three fold the three towns realize that
after two thousand and three when each of

366
00:27:09,41 --> 00:27:13,23
the towns adopted the harbor management
plan and then again in two thousand and

367
00:27:13,24 --> 00:27:16,78
eight when they adopted the harbor
management law the Department of State would

368
00:27:16,79 --> 00:27:21,79
like to see those documents incorporated
into each Times L W R P So that was one

369
00:27:21,80 --> 00:27:26,44
reason why we were able to receive the
grants that we did do the update the other

370
00:27:26,45 --> 00:27:31,26
portions that were of interest particularly
the town of Penfield was the fact as I

371
00:27:31,27 --> 00:27:33,95
mentioned earlier we want to
reduce the scope of the L.W.R. P.

372
00:27:33,96 --> 00:27:37,91
To make it more functional for everybody
within the waterfront area and then

373
00:27:37,92 --> 00:27:44,44
thirdly because of I think.
Issues associated with

374
00:27:45,17 --> 00:27:51,17
perceptions on the south end of the bay
the original document actually tried to

375
00:27:51,18 --> 00:27:55,84
prohibit although it didn't prohibit it
recommended prohibition of any additional

376
00:27:55,85 --> 00:27:59,90
docking at the south end of the bay but it
did that without any studies and it was

377
00:27:59,91 --> 00:28:05,01
just kind of by eyesight only that it was
done since that point in time we have had

378
00:28:05,02 --> 00:28:08,22
additional biological studies done that
indicated that was not going to be

379
00:28:08,23 --> 00:28:12,72
a problem to have additional backing
provided that there was adequate water that

380
00:28:12,89 --> 00:28:15,47
there was adequately inside
support and there was

381
00:28:15,48 --> 00:28:19,61
a ruling this on the part of whoever is
willing to do this to provide additional

382
00:28:19,62 --> 00:28:24,28
water additional access to the water's edge
on him and equate Bay in this recently

383
00:28:24,29 --> 00:28:29,84
just occurred with the South Koreans those
three issues really drove the process

384
00:28:29,85 --> 00:28:32,49
for the town to want to update
itself might be where P.

385
00:28:32,53 --> 00:28:38,19
Is taking quite a while to do it we have
finally finished that the L W R P Just as

386
00:28:38,20 --> 00:28:44,57
a quick note is comprised of seven sections
the first section is the talks about

387
00:28:44,58 --> 00:28:45,64
the existing L.W.R.

388
00:28:45,65 --> 00:28:49,96
Peabody and reason the second one talks
about how they're going to change the third

389
00:28:49,97 --> 00:28:54,51
one addresses the inventory and analyzes
the land use and water use of the service

390
00:28:54,52 --> 00:29:00,35
of a running base within the district.
The third section such for thirteen L.W.

391
00:29:00,36 --> 00:29:00,76
Or P.P.

392
00:29:00,77 --> 00:29:05,95
Policies those are the state policies that
were required to comply with the fourth

393
00:29:05,96 --> 00:29:12,00
one discusses the land of water use projects
to fit the district and so the section

394
00:29:12,14 --> 00:29:16,62
discusses techniques and local implementation
how we would do these projects in

395
00:29:16,81 --> 00:29:21,23
concert with the state of New York. The
six section addresses state and federal

396
00:29:21,24 --> 00:29:25,87
actions and programs likely to affect
implementation. In the sub of policy

397
00:29:25,88 --> 00:29:29,75
addresses local commitments in consultation
with federal state and regional

398
00:29:29,76 --> 00:29:33,20
agencies of the local commitment would be
that we would actually put up money as

399
00:29:33,21 --> 00:29:37,09
well as them in terms of our grant programs
and we would work with each of those

400
00:29:37,10 --> 00:29:41,96
state federal agencies and regionally
disease to ensure compliance with whatever

401
00:29:41,97 --> 00:29:45,35
project we propose the interesting
thing about the L.W.O.P.

402
00:29:45,36 --> 00:29:49,00
Also is it's to see it's to ended and
that we have to comply with state

403
00:29:49,01 --> 00:29:51,45
requirements but the state
of New York also S.

404
00:29:51,46 --> 00:29:54,50
Comply with requirements set forth
within the realm of your P.

405
00:29:54,51 --> 00:29:56,56
For instance if the state the O.T.

406
00:29:56,57 --> 00:30:00,10
Determines that they'd like to widen Empire
Boulevard to six lanes instead of the

407
00:30:00,11 --> 00:30:02,63
current four the L.W.O.P.

408
00:30:02,64 --> 00:30:04,48
Does not recommend that to occur so as

409
00:30:04,49 --> 00:30:08,40
a result they would theoretically not
be permitted to do it or if they were

410
00:30:08,41 --> 00:30:12,53
permitted to do it they would have to
demonstrate why it was necessary to do it and

411
00:30:12,54 --> 00:30:16,38
how they would comply with the other
components of the Ellaby harpy So that is

412
00:30:16,39 --> 00:30:21,08
a nice feature that the towns receive
because of their their partnership with the

413
00:30:21,09 --> 00:30:25,05
state. There are some appendices
to the L B R A P There's

414
00:30:25,06 --> 00:30:29,14
a local consistency law that we will
adopt as part of the L.R.B. R.P.

415
00:30:29,15 --> 00:30:32,39
There's currently one in place that's
pretty much the exact same one that we have

416
00:30:32,40 --> 00:30:35,67
in place now. The ironically they have

417
00:30:35,68 --> 00:30:41,06
a management plan by reference they want
to live with that as Kerry knows she and I

418
00:30:41,07 --> 00:30:44,56
are working with the town of Webster right
now to update that plan which is now.

419
00:30:45,51 --> 00:30:49,40
Twelve years are about twelve years old
so we're doing that in the process of

420
00:30:50,02 --> 00:30:53,02
discussing all the every day activities
that are occurring on the bay and how they

421
00:30:53,03 --> 00:30:54,25
relate to the L.W.R.

422
00:30:54,26 --> 00:30:58,74
Piece there is the harbor management law
which we will be looking at probably next

423
00:30:58,75 --> 00:31:03,77
year as determining whether or not it's
in compliance with the L W R P and her

424
00:31:03,78 --> 00:31:05,88
management plan and finally there's

425
00:31:05,89 --> 00:31:12,19
a coastal fish and wildlife habitat. Graph
as as an appendix to the document as

426
00:31:12,20 --> 00:31:16,23
well which is required We've also created
new mapping the original mapping in the

427
00:31:16,24 --> 00:31:17,32
old L.W. R.P.

428
00:31:17,42 --> 00:31:18,14
It was done in

429
00:31:18,15 --> 00:31:22,22
a time when we didn't have computers and
we didn't have artists and they're very

430
00:31:22,23 --> 00:31:26,75
hard to read and they're they're outdated
so we have all the brain mapping there

431
00:31:27,13 --> 00:31:31,47
actually eighteen new maps that address
all the issues that we're dealing with in

432
00:31:31,48 --> 00:31:37,58
the all that we want peace. And that's
pretty much it. Thank you thanks you and

433
00:31:37,59 --> 00:31:43,76
thanks to that that history certainly has
been I recall correctly about twenty four

434
00:31:43,77 --> 00:31:50,74
years. Since the last updated
you know that. That the three

435
00:31:50,75 --> 00:31:56,17
towns have been coming together and
trying to move us along I give credit to

436
00:31:56,42 --> 00:32:01,35
certainly to yourself and to watch ironic
point that really have to have done

437
00:32:01,77 --> 00:32:06,89
a lot of the work on that and our friends
to the north of us are trying to play

438
00:32:06,90 --> 00:32:11,63
a little catch up but hopefully they get
they get there as well because I think

439
00:32:11,64 --> 00:32:16,91
it's important that it all it all finally
comes to mind finally comes together so.

440
00:32:18,05 --> 00:32:24,43
At this point all open it up to the
board for any questions or comments

441
00:32:25,42 --> 00:32:30,98
you know board that we've been talking
about this for the last several months and

442
00:32:31,44 --> 00:32:37,88
has been keeping us apprised of his
progress Mr Rob Morris been our

443
00:32:37,89 --> 00:32:43,97
liaison to to this process
as well so any any initial

444
00:32:44,39 --> 00:32:49,27
questions. Comments for Mr Costello
at this time before we open it up to.

445
00:32:51,33 --> 00:32:56,93
The public I would just comment in addition
to the maps figures that are included

446
00:32:56,94 --> 00:33:03,10
in the plan include our cut plan from two
thousand and ten as well as I believe

447
00:33:03,33 --> 00:33:08,44
some recommendations regarding Allison parks
the master plan related Elson park so

448
00:33:08,45 --> 00:33:10,85
this is a another example of us

449
00:33:10,90 --> 00:33:17,62
a smaller. More concise plan that works in
conjunction with our other plans within

450
00:33:17,63 --> 00:33:21,77
the town for those have been looked at and
reviewed to make sure this conforms with

451
00:33:21,78 --> 00:33:26,68
recommendations that the public had made
with respect to the comp plan and other

452
00:33:26,69 --> 00:33:33,12
plans That's correct. I also want to note
that we have had. I'm sorry we've had

453
00:33:33,13 --> 00:33:37,50
a local water from realization plan update
on the Web site it's easy to get to you

454
00:33:37,51 --> 00:33:43,75
can go to quickly if you get on line
at the. Org click links and then hit

455
00:33:44,33 --> 00:33:50,79
your P. And it will pop up it's
there for all of us. Just give us

456
00:33:50,80 --> 00:33:55,75
a section of court documents and you
know back before I was out of town board

457
00:33:56,14 --> 00:34:00,65
Revitalization Committee for the waterfront
back in the regional That's right and

458
00:34:01,13 --> 00:34:06,88
you have sewers back then.
And then I mean it's area.

459
00:34:08,36 --> 00:34:10,07
Trying to bring it back and have

460
00:34:10,08 --> 00:34:16,03
a document to support getting grant
money. For the revitalization it's very

461
00:34:16,04 --> 00:34:20,75
important to keep it up to date I think
is I think a smart move to make in

462
00:34:20,76 --> 00:34:26,52
a smaller because back then we were we were
concerned with areas that really in the

463
00:34:26,53 --> 00:34:31,20
end wasn't part of the waterfront it was
pretty expansive it's funny because

464
00:34:31,21 --> 00:34:35,81
sanitary story of that time is one of the
main recommendations. Because of the

465
00:34:35,82 --> 00:34:40,64
album your people were able to secure
funding to allow that to occur has been

466
00:34:40,65 --> 00:34:42,70
a good program to the town
of Penfield we've received

467
00:34:42,71 --> 00:34:44,87
a lot of grant money for it but we've done

468
00:34:44,88 --> 00:34:48,55
a lot of nice things down there to try and
bring what was at one time an industrial

469
00:34:48,66 --> 00:34:53,21
area exactly back to something that can
all be proud of this important time and I

470
00:34:53,22 --> 00:34:59,31
think to. Tell him what Linda saying to
make it more concise you know my review of

471
00:34:59,35 --> 00:35:05,28
the prior plan versus now the summary and
where we're at now with that proposed is

472
00:35:05,29 --> 00:35:10,09
that you're not only confining the area
so that when it comes to grants and

473
00:35:10,10 --> 00:35:16,02
approvals you really focusing on what is
absolutely necessary and what is also

474
00:35:16,03 --> 00:35:21,15
recommended but also you're not
constraining landowners who may have been

475
00:35:21,23 --> 00:35:27,05
a part of the plan that it's not necessary
for them to be constrained in that way

476
00:35:27,19 --> 00:35:30,75
it was it was probably. For them because
they had to fill out additional paperwork

477
00:35:30,76 --> 00:35:34,71
that was difficult to do on their own and
certainly I spent many hours with people

478
00:35:34,72 --> 00:35:39,48
trying to fill out long documents that you
know technically it's better for them

479
00:35:39,49 --> 00:35:46,12
now they're not involved in this situation.
Thank goodness we survived with some

480
00:35:46,48 --> 00:35:53,21
comments. Good. To see you know
their comments at this time let's

481
00:35:53,40 --> 00:35:59,13
open it up to to the audience is there
anyone that signed up Amy to speak to this

482
00:35:59,14 --> 00:36:05,28
particular matter yes Carrie.
Again Welcome Carrie

483
00:36:05,91 --> 00:36:11,38
thank you good evening. I need to give my
address for the record no I think it's

484
00:36:12,06 --> 00:36:17,06
the chant of ironic way to address it's
fifteen pensioners circle Penfield New York

485
00:36:17,07 --> 00:36:20,50
actually. I could do

486
00:36:20,51 --> 00:36:26,87
a job. Yes So I get to wear two hats I'm
a resident of the town of Penfield and

487
00:36:26,88 --> 00:36:31,57
a planning and zoning director or administrator
sees me and I'm running quite And

488
00:36:31,58 --> 00:36:38,39
so I understand ps benefits from both the
perspective of the resident and also

489
00:36:38,89 --> 00:36:39,71
as a as

490
00:36:39,72 --> 00:36:45,45
a planner so I just wanted to speak really
briefly to support the town's adoption

491
00:36:45,46 --> 00:36:49,84
of this plan of the update it's really
critical to have current documents to have

492
00:36:49,85 --> 00:36:55,56
current planning policies and guides
that reflect up did information about

493
00:36:56,07 --> 00:37:00,43
environmental conditions and economic
development and development priorities and

494
00:37:00,44 --> 00:37:05,62
needs and I think this document does that
really well the revised boundary makes

495
00:37:05,63 --> 00:37:06,41
a lot of sense for

496
00:37:06,42 --> 00:37:11,95
a lot of different reasons and that's all
I really wanted to say was just. To thank

497
00:37:11,96 --> 00:37:17,69
the town for taking up the update and
carrying it through and hopefully adopting it

498
00:37:18,27 --> 00:37:25,10
as it stands tall THANK YOU
THANK YOU THANK YOU Kerry. Sure

499
00:37:25,11 --> 00:37:30,39
anyone else OK sure anyone in the
audience. That would like to address this

500
00:37:30,45 --> 00:37:33,47
particular item P update.

501
00:37:37,20 --> 00:37:42,40
OK. Scene board any additional comments.

502
00:37:44,28 --> 00:37:50,90
Or questions. Mr Costello any anything
additional that you would like to add to the

503
00:37:50,91 --> 00:37:55,26
record that you did not include in your
original code the only thing I'd like to

504
00:37:55,27 --> 00:37:59,04
add is the fact that we are currently
working with the Monroe County plan

505
00:37:59,05 --> 00:38:00,60
a department of the thirty nine M.

506
00:38:00,61 --> 00:38:05,43
Review and you know the board obviously
can't take any action until we see that

507
00:38:05,44 --> 00:38:09,61
document and address any concerns that are
with then it will certainly do that once

508
00:38:09,62 --> 00:38:14,91
we receive it and I will also note that the
Department of State was the only other

509
00:38:14,92 --> 00:38:18,05
agency that was involved in the
review process under Seeker was

510
00:38:18,06 --> 00:38:20,10
a court need to review
process we did receive

511
00:38:20,11 --> 00:38:23,87
a letter from them indicating that they did
not want to be the lead agency in this

512
00:38:23,88 --> 00:38:27,41
project and that they recommend that the
board be the lead agency as it was the

513
00:38:27,42 --> 00:38:33,46
only other agency involved.
With that on the record. OK.

514
00:38:35,05 --> 00:38:41,28
Great thank you again similar to the last
A public hearing the next opportunity or

515
00:38:41,29 --> 00:38:45,27
the earliest opportunity to discuss this
will be at our work session that is on the

516
00:38:45,28 --> 00:38:50,71
twenty eighth my guess is that because
there are still some outstanding I'm

517
00:38:50,72 --> 00:38:56,52
specifically two thirty nine am and
you know any other items maybe

518
00:38:56,53 --> 00:39:01,63
a couple of weeks before we're ready to
bring that to the agenda and to the table

519
00:39:02,28 --> 00:39:09,24
but again we'll keep an eye on the agenda
on the website Penfield dot org see no

520
00:39:09,25 --> 00:39:15,89
further comments I'll declare this public
care hearing closed and will continue

521
00:39:15,90 --> 00:39:19,32
on with our agenda and will be

522
00:39:19,33 --> 00:39:25,99
a communications announcements and I'll
first recognize our town clerk Thank you Mr

523
00:39:26,00 --> 00:39:31,28
Supervisor. In reference. To information
pertaining to public hearings and

524
00:39:31,29 --> 00:39:34,32
properties under review a
reminder that there is

525
00:39:34,33 --> 00:39:39,54
a dedicated link on the town's home page
for the town or agendas and the public

526
00:39:39,55 --> 00:39:45,60
hearings for residents homeowners associations
and other research details of the

527
00:39:45,61 --> 00:39:50,32
meetings we will continue to
send a postcard notifications as

528
00:39:50,33 --> 00:39:56,71
a courtesy to neighborhoods affected by
future applications I do want to mention to

529
00:39:56,72 --> 00:40:01,95
everyone that recently the town of Penfield
earned top ranking among the municipal

530
00:40:01,96 --> 00:40:03,76
websites in New York state and

531
00:40:03,77 --> 00:40:08,29
a report that was put out by the vampire
Center for Public Policy and the town's

532
00:40:08,30 --> 00:40:13,46
website has become an essential part of
daily business and is used regularly by our

533
00:40:13,47 --> 00:40:19,13
residents in the general public. And I'd
like to mention that in partnership with

534
00:40:19,14 --> 00:40:24,65
minor county the next pass part port night
will be held April fourteenth from five

535
00:40:24,66 --> 00:40:26,18
thirty to seven thirty P.M.

536
00:40:26,19 --> 00:40:30,31
At the Town Hall and stay tuned for more
information as we get closer to the day

537
00:40:30,83 --> 00:40:31,22
thank you.

538
00:40:37,83 --> 00:40:42,90
Squint Thank you Mr Supervisor just one
quick announcement and A R P tax aide will

539
00:40:42,92 --> 00:40:47,72
be offering free income tax preparation
to low and middle income taxpayers from

540
00:40:47,74 --> 00:40:52,43
Penn field with special attention to those
sixty and older at the community center

541
00:40:52,47 --> 00:40:56,06
one nine hundred eighty five faired
road the service will be available by

542
00:40:56,07 --> 00:41:01,32
appointment only on Wednesday mornings
February fourth through April eight please

543
00:41:01,34 --> 00:41:06,24
call three four zero eight six five
five and select option six to make an

544
00:41:06,25 --> 00:41:11,13
appointment Thank you. I have just one
announcement tonight the pencil heritage

545
00:41:11,14 --> 00:41:16,60
associations next program people in Penn
fields past and now will be held Sunday

546
00:41:16,61 --> 00:41:20,00
January twenty fifth from
two thirty to four P.M.

547
00:41:20,01 --> 00:41:24,62
In the Braman room at the library who are
those brave people who made Penfield what

548
00:41:24,63 --> 00:41:27,51
it is today the heritage So
CA Sion will take you back

549
00:41:27,52 --> 00:41:31,51
a few hundred years that some of the movers
and shakers will actually share their

550
00:41:31,52 --> 00:41:36,68
stories for more information please visit
the library dot org We certainly thank

551
00:41:36,69 --> 00:41:40,97
the librarian Herod's Association and
like to thank my mother Jean Casey for

552
00:41:40,98 --> 00:41:45,49
helping to coordinate that program once
again for their association Thank you.

553
00:41:46,77 --> 00:41:51,13
Thank you Mr Supervisor please mark your
calendars the Penfield trails committee

554
00:41:51,30 --> 00:41:56,76
annual hiker's Gymboree will be held on
Saturday Feb fourteenth at ten am at the

555
00:41:56,77 --> 00:42:02,09
Penfield town hall the public is invited
to come and learn about all the programs

556
00:42:02,15 --> 00:42:07,04
in the greater Rochester area at this free
event all groups in the Rochester area

557
00:42:07,05 --> 00:42:11,53
that will host hiking programs in two
thousand and fifteen are invited to

558
00:42:11,54 --> 00:42:16,21
participate to meet the public and to
promote their individual programs groups

559
00:42:16,22 --> 00:42:21,45
wishing to participate can call Penfield
recreation three four zero eight six five

560
00:42:21,46 --> 00:42:27,69
five extension six. Also Penfield
recreations deer program and its daytime

561
00:42:27,70 --> 00:42:33,13
education recreation has another unique
and exciting fundraiser coming up on

562
00:42:33,14 --> 00:42:35,93
Thursday February twelfth it is

563
00:42:35,97 --> 00:42:41,73
a masterpiece gala which includes
an arts in art auction in

564
00:42:41,74 --> 00:42:45,11
a mystery dinner the event
kicks off at six P.M.

565
00:42:45,12 --> 00:42:50,76
With an art exhibit in appetizers followed
by dinner at seven P.M. Then eight P.M.

566
00:42:50,80 --> 00:42:51,14
There will be

567
00:42:51,15 --> 00:42:56,98
a live auction where the masterpiece
inspired game comes to life or start with

568
00:42:56,99 --> 00:43:01,21
a masterpiece inspired game comes to life
for more details and information about

569
00:43:01,22 --> 00:43:06,46
how to participate please see the new
Penfield winter spring brochure page thirty

570
00:43:06,47 --> 00:43:08,08
five which contains

571
00:43:08,09 --> 00:43:13,70
a complete write up of this unique opportunity
or visit Penfield Rock dot org Thank

572
00:43:13,71 --> 00:43:20,24
you. So last night I had my first community
chat of the year my next one will be in

573
00:43:20,25 --> 00:43:25,22
February I'll be Tuesday February seventeenth
from five to seven new book Area

574
00:43:25,58 --> 00:43:30,60
library in my second announcement is
the pedophile school district Penfield

575
00:43:30,61 --> 00:43:33,40
recreation and the east
side Family Y.M.C.A.

576
00:43:33,74 --> 00:43:38,66
Working together to offer an after school
program for students grades kindergarten

577
00:43:38,70 --> 00:43:43,43
through fifth grade unscheduled half day
of school on Friday January thirtieth

578
00:43:43,94 --> 00:43:48,52
busing will be provided for your child's
school to Bay Trail middle school where

579
00:43:48,53 --> 00:43:52,77
the program will be held children participating
should bring their lunch to school

580
00:43:52,78 --> 00:43:56,97
and the afternoon snack will be provided
the program fee is fifteen dollars per

581
00:43:56,98 --> 00:44:03,40
child and parent pickup is until six pm
register your child today it Penfield org

582
00:44:04,03 --> 00:44:10,85
That's it thank you. OK
very good move on to public

583
00:44:10,86 --> 00:44:15,89
participation there are two opportunities
to address the board on any matter at

584
00:44:15,90 --> 00:44:20,26
this time and then again at the end of
the meeting you can do that one of three

585
00:44:20,27 --> 00:44:25,62
ways if you're here in the audience we'll
get to those that signed in first those

586
00:44:25,63 --> 00:44:30,54
that did not sign in that or that are here
will be then given the opportunity to

587
00:44:30,55 --> 00:44:37,41
speak after that you can also call in at
three four zero eight seven seven one or

588
00:44:37,42 --> 00:44:40,40
you can log on to Penfield
dot org And you can get

589
00:44:40,41 --> 00:44:46,39
a message right up here so with that I'll
ask our clerk to read those names that

590
00:44:46,40 --> 00:44:47,55
have signed up to speak.

591
00:44:59,07 --> 00:45:03,76
Happy New Year and the New Year to you
thank you Bob Reid to seventy five party

592
00:45:03,77 --> 00:45:08,33
drive and I'm here tonight as they usually
end to talk about the Baker Commodities

593
00:45:08,34 --> 00:45:10,36
if you. Were

594
00:45:10,40 --> 00:45:16,82
a couple of months past the. Three months
past the public information meeting no.

595
00:45:17,90 --> 00:45:23,70
Two months and were were interested in
knowing if you've made progress with Mr

596
00:45:23,71 --> 00:45:28,54
D'Amato on an action list of issues that
came out of that meeting I have some other

597
00:45:28,55 --> 00:45:30,53
things to talk about but I
would like to pause for

598
00:45:30,54 --> 00:45:33,50
a minute more than happy
to comment it's been

599
00:45:33,51 --> 00:45:37,74
a couple weeks since I've
last spoken with D.C.

600
00:45:38,11 --> 00:45:43,04
I know that they were working
on a number of items as

601
00:45:43,05 --> 00:45:47,56
a result of the public hearing I know
that they were and have been in regular

602
00:45:47,57 --> 00:45:53,26
contact with Baker Baker and indicated at
that meeting that they were going to be

603
00:45:53,51 --> 00:45:58,69
they had ordered and they were going to
be receiving some new equipment so I know

604
00:45:58,70 --> 00:45:59,16
D.C.

605
00:45:59,17 --> 00:46:03,57
Has been having conversations with them as
I said Bob I have not spoken to him and

606
00:46:03,75 --> 00:46:05,47
in the last couple weeks I know that

607
00:46:06,39 --> 00:46:12,82
a note that I responded I think to Tim
Murphy. Around November sixth he said that

608
00:46:12,89 --> 00:46:19,81
we'd hoped to have more information
by about mid. January so

609
00:46:20,37 --> 00:46:25,14
we're at that time frame.
Although I'll certainly make it

610
00:46:25,15 --> 00:46:29,95
a point over the next couple of days to
reach out to. Mr tomato's office and see

611
00:46:29,96 --> 00:46:34,15
where things are at that end
OK and you have sort of

612
00:46:34,16 --> 00:46:37,74
a punch list of things that came out of
the meeting that you want to discuss with

613
00:46:37,75 --> 00:46:43,99
him and OK good we would like to see some
progress on that and I have not certainly

614
00:46:44,00 --> 00:46:49,52
have not forgotten about that and I know
that when I did last speak they were

615
00:46:49,53 --> 00:46:49,99
looking at

616
00:46:50,00 --> 00:46:55,12
a number of things including I think is
they've mentioned that public information

617
00:46:55,13 --> 00:47:01,55
meeting. You know some. Updates or
amendments or whatever the proper

618
00:47:01,56 --> 00:47:05,94
terminology was permitted selves I
know that they have been looking at

619
00:47:06,22 --> 00:47:12,69
a lot of that activity. You know that
we're interested in seeing that the

620
00:47:13,02 --> 00:47:16,28
air is tested over the plant and
in our neighborhood we feel that's

621
00:47:16,29 --> 00:47:21,08
a major issue and we hope that will be
addressed we thought that the neighbor Lydia

622
00:47:21,18 --> 00:47:26,99
Palmer made a wonderful suggestion
Alrighty. Sponsors I guess

623
00:47:27,00 --> 00:47:31,51
a pollution prevention Institute and you
already received this in an in an e-mail

624
00:47:31,56 --> 00:47:34,80
and Mr D'Amato is on the board
there and we think that's

625
00:47:34,81 --> 00:47:39,72
a terrific university town neighborhood
partnership that could lead to testing that

626
00:47:39,73 --> 00:47:44,70
might not be too expensive. And
you know that we're hoping for

627
00:47:44,71 --> 00:47:51,18
a more rapid response to other complaints
rather than. Just waiting for the plant

628
00:47:51,19 --> 00:47:54,52
manager to respond say there
was a problem or there wasn't

629
00:47:54,53 --> 00:48:01,06
a problem but some kind of more
more rapid and effective regulatory

630
00:48:01,07 --> 00:48:05,10
response to order complaints we kind of
feel at the moment and in the past it's

631
00:48:05,11 --> 00:48:11,98
been the honor system you know. We go with
what the plant manager says is wrong or

632
00:48:11,99 --> 00:48:16,13
isn't wrong and that's it and nobody
really checks up except perhaps once

633
00:48:16,14 --> 00:48:20,03
a year in the past anyway
once a year when the D.C.

634
00:48:20,04 --> 00:48:26,77
Visits and looks at the records. And I
know I know Mr D'Amato when the amount of

635
00:48:26,78 --> 00:48:33,43
when he was here to indicated that. There
was going to be more regular reviews

636
00:48:33,44 --> 00:48:39,54
discussions and follow up with me he see
and I would and I would expect that as

637
00:48:39,55 --> 00:48:43,27
they come back with some of
their follow up we might learn

638
00:48:43,28 --> 00:48:49,33
a little bit more what that means by
regularity as we go through on the subject of

639
00:48:49,34 --> 00:48:49,93
the D.E.C.

640
00:48:49,94 --> 00:48:55,51
And Mr D'Amato. It was wonderful to see Mr
Quinn stand up at the public information

641
00:48:55,52 --> 00:49:01,59
meeting and and chide Mr D'Amato for his
response to the to your request that he

642
00:49:01,75 --> 00:49:05,55
reevaluate Baker's compliance
with state permit it was

643
00:49:05,56 --> 00:49:07,97
a wonderful thing but there is

644
00:49:07,98 --> 00:49:12,23
a town permit that needs to be refined
reevaluated and which the town has

645
00:49:12,24 --> 00:49:14,20
apparently up to this point not taking

646
00:49:14,21 --> 00:49:19,81
a close look at the non-conforming use
permit that Baker got when they purchased

647
00:49:19,82 --> 00:49:24,74
the plant from. The staff and that corporation
in the in the early one nine hundred

648
00:49:24,75 --> 00:49:25,27
eighty S.

649
00:49:25,27 --> 00:49:31,95
. That's something in the town's purview
and we know that it limits Baker's

650
00:49:32,04 --> 00:49:38,54
operation to the size and scope of the
staff and that company and all reasonable

651
00:49:39,42 --> 00:49:46,32
opinion suggests that they've greatly
expanded the operation we don't have facts

652
00:49:46,33 --> 00:49:52,13
and figures and and as you recall when
Mr Burns asked Bill Schneider the plant

653
00:49:52,14 --> 00:49:56,36
manager at the public information meeting
how much tonnage they process you know he

654
00:49:56,37 --> 00:50:01,44
said I can't tell you that I don't know
exactly where the proprietary information

655
00:50:01,45 --> 00:50:07,58
or it's confidential but. We're pretty
sure that the plant is way oversized and

656
00:50:08,01 --> 00:50:11,06
from what's happened background and that
could be an aspect of why we're having

657
00:50:11,07 --> 00:50:16,24
more odors more stuff going in. Texas
the order of eight minute Quitman.

658
00:50:18,27 --> 00:50:22,25
And we're not suggesting that they should
be shut down because they're in violation

659
00:50:22,26 --> 00:50:27,23
of their permit but that the permit needs
to be reexamined the way you reexamined

660
00:50:27,24 --> 00:50:29,62
the local waterfront reevaluation

661
00:50:29,76 --> 00:50:35,37
a revival of it is ation plan and upgraded
and other town ordinances and and issues

662
00:50:35,72 --> 00:50:41,52
needs to be reevaluated updated and. If
they're going to be allowed to operate at

663
00:50:41,53 --> 00:50:46,94
a hugely expanded scope and serve all of
western and central New York and we've

664
00:50:46,95 --> 00:50:50,82
said that they do an important service
to Western and sent central New York and

665
00:50:50,83 --> 00:50:55,58
processing this stuff then there needs to
be adequate control for what they do and

666
00:50:55,59 --> 00:51:00,31
adequate follow up when they don't do
it well they need to be consequences we

667
00:51:00,32 --> 00:51:04,36
talked about fines and sanctions so those
things are very very important to us.

668
00:51:09,49 --> 00:51:12,39
Now in July the neighborhood presented

669
00:51:12,40 --> 00:51:18,05
a petition to the board with one hundred
thirty or so signatures on it seven points

670
00:51:18,19 --> 00:51:20,46
and. We've yet to get

671
00:51:20,47 --> 00:51:23,59
a written response from the board
we haven't actually asked for

672
00:51:23,60 --> 00:51:28,28
a written response we've talked
about some of the issues but it was

673
00:51:28,29 --> 00:51:33,04
a formal document and and we would like
to see a formal response I have sent you

674
00:51:33,05 --> 00:51:38,14
a couple of e-mails on that Tony and I
haven't heard back from you on either one I

675
00:51:38,15 --> 00:51:44,65
soon that you got them I know there were
some computer issues with the town but we

676
00:51:44,66 --> 00:51:45,23
would like to see

677
00:51:45,24 --> 00:51:51,14
a formal response to the petition. And
we feel it's very briefly six of those

678
00:51:51,15 --> 00:51:56,95
elements that the survey needs to be done
of all the surrounding neighborhoods. To

679
00:51:56,96 --> 00:52:00,66
ascertain the real level
of the problem and we have

680
00:52:00,67 --> 00:52:04,24
a relatively small reporting
group it would also provide

681
00:52:04,78 --> 00:52:07,41
a way to touch base with
people to establish

682
00:52:07,66 --> 00:52:11,79
a much larger reporting group so we
really know what's what how the plant is

683
00:52:11,80 --> 00:52:18,06
affecting people now and in the future.
The testing we've already talked about

684
00:52:18,59 --> 00:52:22,92
a truly outside expert
evaluation and not by S.E.P.

685
00:52:22,93 --> 00:52:24,44
Control and

686
00:52:24,45 --> 00:52:31,06
a thorough one that needs to be done. The
not conforming is permit reevaluation

687
00:52:31,46 --> 00:52:37,61
and the the publication of the secret
agreement between the town of Penfield in one

688
00:52:37,62 --> 00:52:43,59
thousand nine hundred nine and Baker
Commodities we feel those things need to be

689
00:52:43,60 --> 00:52:49,24
addressed and if. You don't feel that any
of these things should be accomplished

690
00:52:49,32 --> 00:52:56,26
then we'd like to see your reasons
and I think that's fair. To go back

691
00:52:56,27 --> 00:53:03,04
to your e-mail to Tim Murphy that
you referred to. The issues that

692
00:53:03,25 --> 00:53:08,04
you hope to hear from Mr D'Amato on one
of them was new equipment from Baker I

693
00:53:08,05 --> 00:53:13,65
think you also mentioned something about
record keeping. Can you elaborate on that

694
00:53:13,66 --> 00:53:19,23
at all. Something going to change with
record keeping for Baker or whether

695
00:53:19,24 --> 00:53:23,74
residence in the way we report order
to play I don't I don't recall.

696
00:53:26,26 --> 00:53:31,14
You know changing you know that formatting
mean that we design or stand at the

697
00:53:31,15 --> 00:53:37,59
format still is that if there is an order
that gets sent in to Baker and it's

698
00:53:37,60 --> 00:53:41,12
a you know pretty broad or or

699
00:53:41,13 --> 00:53:47,95
a number of different dots on that
on that list so I didn't I didn't

700
00:53:47,96 --> 00:53:54,13
recall that being changed modified but
I do recall some discussions that

701
00:53:54,88 --> 00:54:00,36
the CME Baker have had as as far
as some records that they keep or.

702
00:54:01,96 --> 00:54:07,46
Either either expanding or or adding to
some of the records that they keep I do

703
00:54:07,47 --> 00:54:12,19
recall that I mean I have to go back and
check my notes in more detail but I

704
00:54:12,20 --> 00:54:17,26
believe that that was one of the
things that that model had made

705
00:54:17,27 --> 00:54:18,24
a recommendation or

706
00:54:18,25 --> 00:54:25,06
a comment on is that providing some
additional. Information. And details on the

707
00:54:25,07 --> 00:54:30,26
record keeping OK your e-mail just used
the word record keeping in the context of

708
00:54:30,50 --> 00:54:35,32
some new issues that might be coming
along and looking back originally in the

709
00:54:35,33 --> 00:54:39,49
eighty's when we had problems
there was a link the D.E.C.

710
00:54:39,50 --> 00:54:39,71
Owed

711
00:54:39,72 --> 00:54:46,04
a report form that we were supposed to
fill out. For each order complaint kind of

712
00:54:46,05 --> 00:54:50,19
an onerous burden and if you wanted to
report directly to the plant you had to call

713
00:54:50,20 --> 00:54:53,24
the answering machine and
the answering machine was

714
00:54:53,25 --> 00:54:59,66
a link the. He's of questions you know right
and we rather we want good information

715
00:54:59,67 --> 00:55:02,82
but we don't want to go back we don't
want to make it any harder for people to

716
00:55:02,83 --> 00:55:09,35
report order but of problems than it
already is. So I know that there's there's

717
00:55:09,36 --> 00:55:16,06
been one just recently that that was
reported and. To the best of my

718
00:55:16,07 --> 00:55:22,94
knowledge that that got reported in through
the way that it has been. And you know

719
00:55:22,95 --> 00:55:28,07
so to the best of my knowledge that has not
changed at all so that doesn't require

720
00:55:28,08 --> 00:55:32,54
a lengthy. Voicemail
to the plant it's just

721
00:55:32,55 --> 00:55:36,17
a blast note that goes
out that is copied into

722
00:55:36,18 --> 00:55:41,60
a number of folks see this
Ford. Baker commodity and

723
00:55:41,87 --> 00:55:48,87
a number of neighbors that that
are on the list OK good. Where we

724
00:55:48,88 --> 00:55:54,61
are right now as we've seen an improvement
over the two worst years that we've had

725
00:55:55,58 --> 00:56:01,80
in January we had three other complaints.
In twenty fourteen we had eight in two

726
00:56:01,81 --> 00:56:07,68
thousand and thirteen we had eight. That
looks like quite an improvement but when

727
00:56:07,69 --> 00:56:13,84
you smell it in January. You know
it's very powerful that there's

728
00:56:13,85 --> 00:56:19,85
a lot of effluent there because the nose
doesn't work very well in January. In the

729
00:56:19,86 --> 00:56:24,18
cold weather. In two thousand and twelve
we had zero in two thousand and eleven we

730
00:56:24,19 --> 00:56:29,41
had one in January in two thousand and
ten we had only two. So we've seen an

731
00:56:29,42 --> 00:56:34,79
improvement over the worst pollution
abuses that we've experienced but we don't

732
00:56:34,80 --> 00:56:41,78
think that we've completely turned the
corner we don't. We want improvement but

733
00:56:41,79 --> 00:56:46,75
not just to the improvement of twenty
eleven or twenty ten or twenty nine the

734
00:56:46,76 --> 00:56:51,08
benchmark that we're looking for is much
closer to what we had between one thousand

735
00:56:51,09 --> 00:56:54,82
nine hundred eighty seven and the end
of two thousand and four and that was

736
00:56:54,83 --> 00:57:01,72
a zero complaints. I'm not sure
if we'll ever get to that point

737
00:57:01,98 --> 00:57:05,80
but that's what we should be aiming at and
if they could do it for that period of

738
00:57:05,81 --> 00:57:12,34
time. They can do it now and I have to say
that for the first three years ninety

739
00:57:12,35 --> 00:57:18,65
seven to two thousand we were ready to jump
on them for anything because that year

740
00:57:18,66 --> 00:57:23,19
ninety six had been so horrible you know
you remember what happened in ninety six

741
00:57:23,20 --> 00:57:27,10
you were on the board at that time and
this room was filled with angry residents

742
00:57:27,11 --> 00:57:32,15
over the problem. So we were and the
promise then was that they would get new

743
00:57:32,16 --> 00:57:37,69
equipment and they would fix it and things
would get better and they did OK but for

744
00:57:37,70 --> 00:57:42,68
those first three years we were ready to
jump on anything and there was nothing to

745
00:57:42,69 --> 00:57:48,54
jump on OK so if they could do it for three
years. And then and then another five

746
00:57:49,56 --> 00:57:53,56
they can do it now or come much closer to
it we're getting three hundred complaints

747
00:57:53,57 --> 00:58:00,09
in January very much worried about
July June July and August. So

748
00:58:00,82 --> 00:58:07,68
I only recall scene one in January so.
At have the others of the others hit

749
00:58:07,69 --> 00:58:14,62
that bride at that broad distribution. And
I realize they've all been. Talking in

750
00:58:14,63 --> 00:58:18,97
terms that it may be one incident but more
than one match so that would be three

751
00:58:19,08 --> 00:58:23,59
like say one day three residents can I think
they were two days and three residents

752
00:58:23,77 --> 00:58:30,60
OK OK. You call an incident on December
I want to say it was around the twenty

753
00:58:30,82 --> 00:58:36,88
sixth of December if I
recall correctly. And I

754
00:58:37,00 --> 00:58:41,25
recall one in January I
mean I'll go back and take

755
00:58:41,26 --> 00:58:45,32
a look but those are the only two that I
recall and of end of year and beginning of

756
00:58:45,33 --> 00:58:51,75
this year. Yeah sure to develop them twenty
six and I don't have the top of my head

757
00:58:51,76 --> 00:58:56,12
what that other day was in January right
but I'm just talking about January three

758
00:58:56,83 --> 00:59:01,77
three complaints and I'll be glad to send
them to you again if you like but we have

759
00:59:01,78 --> 00:59:01,93
had

760
00:59:01,94 --> 00:59:08,18
a discrepancy in the past between your
numbers and mine at least. I think you cited

761
00:59:08,19 --> 00:59:12,49
one hundred fifty nine Well I think I think
over the difference I think where the

762
00:59:12,50 --> 00:59:15,78
difference is Bob is that we take

763
00:59:15,79 --> 00:59:19,50
a look at the number of days and you take

764
00:59:19,51 --> 00:59:26,26
a look so if you have helped one day
one person that small that versus

765
00:59:26,27 --> 00:59:30,87
one day and ten people that's not what.
We count two different days you count

766
00:59:30,91 --> 00:59:35,96
a lot of an incidence. I mean that's that's
that's where that we're interested in

767
00:59:35,97 --> 00:59:39,76
how many people have been affected and
that's simply the number of days but you're

768
00:59:39,77 --> 00:59:44,71
right there's two different ways of
looking at it. And say say we have

769
00:59:44,72 --> 00:59:49,39
a relatively small reporting group you know
you need to reach out with that survey

770
00:59:49,69 --> 00:59:53,86
to all the neighbors at the plant on the
other side of the creek as well as on our

771
00:59:53,87 --> 01:00:00,53
side. That's just about all I have
to say but if you want to come back

772
01:00:01,01 --> 01:00:01,70
can I expect

773
01:00:01,71 --> 01:00:06,83
a written response from the board on
the petition we will we will have

774
01:00:06,84 --> 01:00:12,79
a conversation and we'll follow up with
something in writing to you OK and to the

775
01:00:12,80 --> 01:00:16,68
committee and you know all the members of
the neighborhood I do good thank you and

776
01:00:16,69 --> 01:00:23,17
Bob I have my meal Ousterhout from
Baker responding to January ninth of

777
01:00:23,22 --> 01:00:28,32
January fourteenth and in January fifteenth
so that would be three within you know

778
01:00:28,33 --> 01:00:31,46
and I but the fourteenth and fifteenth
might have been an overlap in terms of

779
01:00:31,78 --> 01:00:35,54
people's And one of the days he
responded on I believe there wasn't

780
01:00:35,55 --> 01:00:41,33
a note of complaint. I have to look at the
records myself but one day he was saying

781
01:00:41,39 --> 01:00:44,44
actually that the one day he said
there was a problem that they had

782
01:00:44,45 --> 01:00:47,12
a shutdown of the thermal
oxidizer I believe was

783
01:00:47,13 --> 01:00:50,32
a day when we didn't have an order complaint
and that was the fifteenth and the

784
01:00:50,33 --> 01:00:54,02
other two other complaints or the other two
days if there were other two other days

785
01:00:54,02 --> 01:00:59,85
. Everything down there was running
normally according to Neil. So.

786
01:01:01,68 --> 01:01:05,49
But we were glad to hear from him but I
don't know I don't think there was any

787
01:01:05,50 --> 01:01:06,87
follow up from the D.C.

788
01:01:06,88 --> 01:01:10,51
And I don't know that anybody from the town
goes down there to look at the records

789
01:01:10,52 --> 01:01:14,13
and the equipment and things like that
is something that has to change I think.

790
01:01:15,45 --> 01:01:22,27
Thank you thank you. Our
next speaker is I know the

791
01:01:22,28 --> 01:01:28,79
next speaker that signed up not happen to
be in our audience right now OK so then

792
01:01:29,05 --> 01:01:35,16
that makes it real easy so then we move on
to those that would like to address the

793
01:01:35,17 --> 01:01:38,42
point but did not sign up and
so I would take that with

794
01:01:38,43 --> 01:01:42,72
a show of hands and go through their seats
to Murphy never want like number number

795
01:01:42,73 --> 01:01:48,28
two. And then number three so
let's start with Mr Murphy.

796
01:02:04,43 --> 01:02:08,33
Good evening Mr Supervisor town board
Happy New Year to Murphy I live it forty

797
01:02:08,34 --> 01:02:12,60
eight kernel drive I had a couple of
comments and observations and then

798
01:02:12,61 --> 01:02:19,10
a couple of questions first just to pick
up on Mr Reed. You know I read your column

799
01:02:19,11 --> 01:02:23,03
Mr Supervisor almost every week and you
know there's normally some really good

800
01:02:23,04 --> 01:02:28,29
information in there but I do recall that
we've never seen anything about the Baker

801
01:02:28,30 --> 01:02:32,80
Commodities issue and I don't know if
that's purposeful or not but it's my

802
01:02:32,81 --> 01:02:36,18
observation is you know that's one of
the mouth pieces the town board has to

803
01:02:36,19 --> 01:02:39,93
communicate with the community surrounding
community especially since the the

804
01:02:39,94 --> 01:02:45,03
Penfield post is more regional now than
it is local to Penn field so it would

805
01:02:45,04 --> 01:02:47,11
always be good to be
putting information out

806
01:02:47,12 --> 01:02:51,14
a question as to what your definition of
regional if right now it seems like all

807
01:02:51,15 --> 01:02:57,37
manner of county. That's the top I'm
still trying to figure it out because it

808
01:02:57,57 --> 01:03:04,48
changes every week when we we get
feedback from them as to when. News

809
01:03:04,49 --> 01:03:09,12
things press releases legals all of those
types of things seem to be changing

810
01:03:09,13 --> 01:03:14,46
almost on a weekly basis but OK
I've noticed that too so so kind of

811
01:03:14,47 --> 01:03:18,57
a negative note never seen anything in
your column about the Baker Commodities

812
01:03:18,58 --> 01:03:22,93
issue on the positive side just this week
we read about the initiative with the

813
01:03:22,94 --> 01:03:26,53
school district and the
facility that park there wasn't

814
01:03:26,54 --> 01:03:29,74
a lot of detail there and I can imagine
it's going to be hard to get buses in and

815
01:03:29,75 --> 01:03:31,93
out of there but just the fact
that you're collaborating is

816
01:03:31,94 --> 01:03:36,86
a really good thing so so just to keep the
record straight you will not see buses

817
01:03:36,87 --> 01:03:43,80
go in and out of there OK that
that location. Is where the

818
01:03:44,12 --> 01:03:50,54
their their equivalent of grounds and
facilities will be peeled off so the bus

819
01:03:50,55 --> 01:03:54,67
garage will be the bus garage and five
mile line road and their grounds and

820
01:03:54,68 --> 01:04:00,93
facilities will move down to that location
so there are no buses coming or going.

821
01:04:01,78 --> 01:04:07,72
Is that they've outgrown the footprint on
five mile line road and transportation

822
01:04:07,73 --> 01:04:14,18
grounds and facilities can no longer.
You know occupy that same space so the

823
01:04:14,19 --> 01:04:19,28
purpose of peeling off was to open up
the space of the bus garage and then to

824
01:04:19,45 --> 01:04:24,69
utilize the space that we have down
there and as you're well aware an empty

825
01:04:24,70 --> 01:04:30,61
building. Very quickly and one
that's occupied certainly.

826
01:04:31,81 --> 01:04:35,88
You know has a better life span
for that so if it ends up being

827
01:04:35,89 --> 01:04:42,35
a win win situation temporarily whatever
temporarily is these days until I think

828
01:04:42,76 --> 01:04:46,13
the school district. What their plan B.

829
01:04:46,14 --> 01:04:51,62
Is but at least it buys them you know
three to five years or thereabouts before

830
01:04:51,63 --> 01:04:55,93
they have to pull the trigger and can
really spend any money. But thanks for the

831
01:04:55,94 --> 01:04:59,88
clarification think of taking the initiative
and it makes sense because that be

832
01:04:59,89 --> 01:05:03,65
a tough in and out for anything that's
oversized absolutely for sure absolutely.

833
01:05:05,05 --> 01:05:08,58
Also just just an observation I went
through the Power Point back in the

834
01:05:08,59 --> 01:05:12,32
organization meeting so I couldn't be
here and I did forward some questions and

835
01:05:12,36 --> 01:05:16,49
I'll give you some time to answer but one
of the things that really you know on the

836
01:05:16,50 --> 01:05:18,90
very first slide you know there was

837
01:05:18,91 --> 01:05:24,07
a reference to elicit liaisons to registered
homeowners associations and maybe that

838
01:05:24,08 --> 01:05:24,29
makes

839
01:05:24,30 --> 01:05:28,30
a difference the word registered but again I
kind of go back to the bigger commodities

840
01:05:28,31 --> 01:05:33,67
issue if we have liaison's to different
parts of the or organize community

841
01:05:33,71 --> 01:05:38,74
shouldn't we also be identifying someone
specifically not just for the order issue

842
01:05:38,75 --> 01:05:43,21
at Baker Commodities But shouldn't we
maybe looking at maybe having different

843
01:05:43,22 --> 01:05:47,29
members of the town board be assigned
to different parts of the community as

844
01:05:47,30 --> 01:05:53,22
a point person whether it's attending
meetings or. Well the like so you're right to

845
01:05:53,23 --> 01:06:00,12
the key the key phrase ology is the organized
you know their years we have seen is

846
01:06:00,13 --> 01:06:06,47
many is nine or more homeowners association
and currently I think we're down to

847
01:06:06,48 --> 01:06:12,13
maybe three if memory serves me correct
and those are ones that specifically have

848
01:06:12,52 --> 01:06:18,85
you know asked to be on that list to receive
information so. That's one you know

849
01:06:18,86 --> 01:06:24,92
whether it's three or thirty. You know
we'll add to that what's happened in the

850
01:06:24,93 --> 01:06:29,95
past is that there was a specific
issue so whatever that might be

851
01:06:30,27 --> 01:06:31,67
a specific issue in around

852
01:06:31,68 --> 01:06:36,06
a neighborhood the neighborhood I
asked to to be on and then over

853
01:06:36,07 --> 01:06:40,83
a period of time asked to drop off
because either the item was no longer of

854
01:06:40,84 --> 01:06:45,26
interest the person that was the point
person moved no one else wanted to take it

855
01:06:45,27 --> 01:06:51,99
on or whatever the whatever the
cases. The board really works

856
01:06:52,65 --> 01:06:59,42
you know when unison that. The board can
be at or address any matter regardless

857
01:06:59,43 --> 01:07:04,22
where it is I mean we don't like some
communities have it broken down into wards or

858
01:07:04,44 --> 01:07:08,46
other districts you know
this board are liked it as

859
01:07:08,47 --> 01:07:13,04
a you know community why candidates and
you know can address any item in any

860
01:07:13,05 --> 01:07:19,07
neighborhood or or particular business
residence anything like that so any and any

861
01:07:19,08 --> 01:07:23,71
and all of us at any time could be you
know part of any project or program and I

862
01:07:23,72 --> 01:07:27,63
was just like you say to him if you know
of something that you'd like one of us to

863
01:07:27,64 --> 01:07:32,93
attend or you can always invite me I'm
always available. Thank you for saying that

864
01:07:33,71 --> 01:07:35,48
just so we're clear to become

865
01:07:35,49 --> 01:07:39,25
a registered organized homeowners association
is that something we have to dress

866
01:07:39,46 --> 01:07:46,35
with mystic loft. And we
have to OK OK you know and

867
01:07:46,39 --> 01:07:53,29
you know certainly you have you
know the baker. Well call the baker

868
01:07:53,34 --> 01:07:57,18
neighborhood for lack of better description
but Baker neighborhood and there is you

869
01:07:57,19 --> 01:08:03,91
know some number of. E-mails and typically
how we communicate you know today you

870
01:08:03,92 --> 01:08:09,82
know via e-mail so we just do blast blast
e-mails out. OK well I'll follow up on

871
01:08:09,83 --> 01:08:16,65
that for sure. I wanted to ask about
something that I had brought up

872
01:08:16,88 --> 01:08:20,51
prior to the start of the budget cycle
or part of the budget cycle and that was

873
01:08:20,52 --> 01:08:26,72
some kind of review or report out about the
outsourcing of knowing. The idea is you

874
01:08:26,73 --> 01:08:27,79
know we can think we did

875
01:08:27,80 --> 01:08:31,39
a good thing and I hope we did but the
numbers usually you know helps tell the

876
01:08:31,40 --> 01:08:36,23
story so you know how many passes what
were the savings what did the redeployed

877
01:08:36,24 --> 01:08:40,97
resources do instead of knowing those
kind of things and I know again we're you

878
01:08:40,98 --> 01:08:46,77
know we're looking at that initiative ongoing
So you know the report out is on the

879
01:08:46,78 --> 01:08:48,23
twenty eight seven P.M.

880
01:08:48,28 --> 01:08:52,60
Great Love to Love to see in the audience
I will be here sir excellent report.

881
01:08:55,60 --> 01:08:58,51
Also we presented a petition and I've sent

882
01:08:58,52 --> 01:09:05,48
a couple of e-mails I got one reply. And
I know it's not the end of the month but

883
01:09:05,49 --> 01:09:10,33
I wanted to take this opportunity just
terribly interested in having something

884
01:09:10,34 --> 01:09:15,40
happen timely and I think you know why and
honestly it doesn't matter who does it

885
01:09:15,65 --> 01:09:20,36
as long as it gets done so is there any
update at this point you could share we

886
01:09:20,37 --> 01:09:26,05
still waiting on. I have not not seen
anything yet from Bruce Bruce had indicated

887
01:09:26,06 --> 01:09:27,04
that he would have

888
01:09:27,05 --> 01:09:33,75
a couple of. Sketches that he would be
bringing in and and presenting to us so

889
01:09:34,16 --> 01:09:37,29
I expect to have those by the end of the
month that was kind of the agreed upon

890
01:09:37,30 --> 01:09:43,32
goal because the interest would be then
to be able to roll that out and then to

891
01:09:43,36 --> 01:09:46,00
actually start on something in

892
01:09:46,01 --> 01:09:52,37
a timely fashion. Kind of consistent with
what you would indicated being done in

893
01:09:52,38 --> 01:09:53,26
a timely in

894
01:09:53,27 --> 01:10:01,73
a timely manner OK so we'll let that
play out over the next thank you. So

895
01:10:02,08 --> 01:10:06,74
there's one other thing here. So talk
to us about the solar on your house.

896
01:10:09,90 --> 01:10:14,21
Well Bob could probably tell you that
you know. Pretty detailed oriented guy

897
01:10:14,22 --> 01:10:19,13
project manager and I like to build things
so that all kind of come together. New

898
01:10:19,15 --> 01:10:19,66
York State has

899
01:10:19,67 --> 01:10:23,41
a great program they do between that the
the government the federal government the

900
01:10:23,41 --> 01:10:30,38
state and you know tax credits plus the.
Rebates or incentives per watt I mean

901
01:10:30,40 --> 01:10:31,24
honestly it's

902
01:10:31,24 --> 01:10:37,06
a big number that becomes. A manageable
number in for us you know we've been home

903
01:10:37,07 --> 01:10:42,17
for twenty years and I have all the graphs
and all the neat stuff and I can see

904
01:10:42,18 --> 01:10:44,40
where the kids went away
and believe me it makes

905
01:10:44,41 --> 01:10:48,74
a difference in your our genie bill believe
me it really does and so the only the

906
01:10:48,75 --> 01:10:53,20
light honestly I kind of put them
all on one time when Home Depot had

907
01:10:53,21 --> 01:10:55,59
a four dollar loss leader
thing and honestly it made

908
01:10:55,60 --> 01:11:01,75
a huge difference but I'm looking forward
to it because I mean what's in me is like

909
01:11:01,86 --> 01:11:06,60
I care less about the costs and just maybe
just the behavior and our neighbors put

910
01:11:06,61 --> 01:11:12,32
them in and we had long talks with them
in their. You know kind of the same mind

911
01:11:12,94 --> 01:11:17,85
but the pleasant surprises is that you
know some of the nicer the estimates are

912
01:11:17,86 --> 01:11:22,53
very conservative so the
the commercial is it's

913
01:11:22,54 --> 01:11:27,32
a good investment and if it doesn't add
to the assessment of your house about it

914
01:11:27,33 --> 01:11:31,19
you know you make the kind of investment
you have to pay back in the short term on

915
01:11:31,20 --> 01:11:34,92
your electric bill and then you go to sell
your house and you can say hey you know

916
01:11:34,93 --> 01:11:36,72
they can tax on it that's

917
01:11:36,73 --> 01:11:41,75
a pretty good win across the board are you
are you going for not zero. We use about

918
01:11:41,76 --> 01:11:43,25
seven thousand kilowatts

919
01:11:44,04 --> 01:11:48,59
a year Tony and we're sized to short of
that as you know you can't go bigger than

920
01:11:48,60 --> 01:11:51,99
one hundred ten percent right because they
don't want you to producing it and you

921
01:11:52,00 --> 01:11:52,61
know be

922
01:11:52,62 --> 01:11:58,18
a profit center right well the answer is yes
and they also encourage better behavior

923
01:11:58,98 --> 01:12:05,64
right timers on your lights. You know
insulation and all those other things that

924
01:12:05,90 --> 01:12:08,79
seem to just shorten that
zero and if I take down

925
01:12:08,80 --> 01:12:15,41
a tree I think it will be there but. One
of the cool things is again you know

926
01:12:15,60 --> 01:12:17,05
Mr Canal about an hour did

927
01:12:17,06 --> 01:12:22,01
a great job in the solar Pathfinder and our
house is not oriented south even though

928
01:12:22,02 --> 01:12:25,48
we're in Taishan citing it's kind of one
of the biggest influences you would think

929
01:12:26,27 --> 01:12:28,56
but. All you can get

930
01:12:28,57 --> 01:12:33,09
a great data capture and again kind of ran
the numbers and you know it just makes

931
01:12:33,10 --> 01:12:34,78
sense financially and again

932
01:12:34,79 --> 01:12:39,33
a frugal Irishman goes for all those kind
of things I'm glad to have you over in.

933
01:12:42,93 --> 01:12:47,83
I'm sure they have an interest so well
let's hope more people would find

934
01:12:47,84 --> 01:12:51,23
a way other communities especially Germany
if you read some of the stories over

935
01:12:51,24 --> 01:12:56,31
there you know they do it for very pragmatic
reasons and again that's you know I

936
01:12:56,32 --> 01:13:01,03
ran the numbers in New York State has
probably the best incentive program right now

937
01:13:01,30 --> 01:13:08,07
you wouldn't think it but so far as.
That's the line. You're welcome I just

938
01:13:08,08 --> 01:13:09,14
remember what I had

939
01:13:09,15 --> 01:13:12,64
a knack I don't I knew I'd break free that
last question so I was trying to just

940
01:13:13,00 --> 01:13:17,48
takes longer and longer all the time so
I know I know I had an action item to

941
01:13:17,49 --> 01:13:23,52
follow up with. In our company because we
do make air quality monitoring equipment

942
01:13:23,78 --> 01:13:26,21
in a business unit that I'm not
associated with and I've talked to

943
01:13:26,22 --> 01:13:29,63
a couple of different people and the
first thing I get reminded of is we're

944
01:13:29,64 --> 01:13:31,39
equipment and instruments
company we're not

945
01:13:31,40 --> 01:13:37,29
a services company. The other thing is quite
honestly they said it is difficult to

946
01:13:37,29 --> 01:13:44,11
. To assess odors you first got to
know what the gas is mission so the

947
01:13:44,12 --> 01:13:48,15
very first thing you have to do is something
we've talked about before is have

948
01:13:48,16 --> 01:13:53,05
a very concerted effort to do a
bag or event. Capture or over

949
01:13:53,06 --> 01:13:57,95
a period of time. And. Group
is the gentleman's name is

950
01:13:57,96 --> 01:14:03,28
a senior technical sales support is that
you know there's companies locally in

951
01:14:03,29 --> 01:14:07,59
Rochester and you mentioned T R C In
particular I'm not familiar with the company

952
01:14:08,07 --> 01:14:12,66
but I did look it up and I believe I sent
to their website. And they do have an

953
01:14:12,67 --> 01:14:16,86
office here in Rochester so again I
think we all know that you know this is

954
01:14:16,87 --> 01:14:21,12
a long road and we're trying to make sure
everybody stays involved and maybe we

955
01:14:21,16 --> 01:14:25,65
reset expectations and maybe get the folks
in Parkview an answer sooner rather than

956
01:14:25,66 --> 01:14:31,10
later whether it be we get academia involved
or we decide we want to pay some money

957
01:14:31,11 --> 01:14:35,70
get a third party involved
which again to me sounds like

958
01:14:35,71 --> 01:14:41,04
a great way to try to get to the end of
the game here. There are companies that

959
01:14:41,59 --> 01:14:46,03
perform the services of Fortune ours does
not get we make the equipment we sell it

960
01:14:46,04 --> 01:14:49,67
to the service providers the engineering
firms I wish I could pull something off

961
01:14:49,68 --> 01:14:54,87
the shelf and put it in Bob's backyard and
say see you know we got your answer but

962
01:14:54,88 --> 01:15:00,19
we know things like that are never that
simple OK. Thank you for your time thanks

963
01:15:00,20 --> 01:15:06,15
for your time good luck with the solar.
OK let's see Ed was next and then.

964
01:15:07,30 --> 01:15:08,21
Blake was next and then

965
01:15:08,22 --> 01:15:17,52
a sorry all right. Blake
and Blake in company. We

966
01:15:17,53 --> 01:15:22,46
don't get even with Patty colors Santo sorry
to interrupt before didn't understand

967
01:15:22,47 --> 01:15:26,24
the order of operations but we just want
to bring to the boards attention that

968
01:15:26,80 --> 01:15:31,68
we've been trying to work through you know
causes office with Benway and also with

969
01:15:31,69 --> 01:15:37,89
the building department. The Ashton Rice
subdivision construction that's going on

970
01:15:37,98 --> 01:15:42,34
and you know some of the adverse effects
that we've been having on our property.

971
01:15:43,83 --> 01:15:48,55
You know Patti came to me last week
when we received those white cards and

972
01:15:48,56 --> 01:15:54,39
questioning as to exactly what's going on
with the construction and I informed her

973
01:15:54,43 --> 01:15:54,72
might be

974
01:15:54,73 --> 01:15:59,05
a good idea for us to go together and at
least let you guys know what's happening

975
01:15:59,89 --> 01:16:01,31
you know speaking for you Patty

976
01:16:01,32 --> 01:16:05,72
a little bit and you know cut me off I'm
not representing it right but I guess when

977
01:16:05,73 --> 01:16:10,28
they were doing instruction the culdesac
actually took I want over there to see

978
01:16:11,19 --> 01:16:16,41
some of the construction the excavation
went right through tree roots that is on

979
01:16:16,42 --> 01:16:20,10
her property boundary.
So you know there's been

980
01:16:20,11 --> 01:16:26,77
a little carelessness with the excavations
with the. Bulldozers backhoes what have

981
01:16:26,78 --> 01:16:33,47
you and just general. Construction going
on there I also kind of saw the way that

982
01:16:33,48 --> 01:16:37,79
all the drainage is lined up there it's
pointing the right towards their backyards

983
01:16:38,35 --> 01:16:41,86
which is you know I've been working out
with cars and with the new way it was to

984
01:16:41,87 --> 01:16:45,98
our understanding there is going to be some
drainage capture going back there to at

985
01:16:45,99 --> 01:16:50,64
least make some swelling and between the
neighbors and the new construction so we'd

986
01:16:50,65 --> 01:16:51,30
have some sort of

987
01:16:51,31 --> 01:16:56,45
a buffer zone created as it will so that
water runoff from that new subdivision

988
01:16:56,62 --> 01:17:02,03
won't be affecting all of our properties.
Did you have any other trees that been

989
01:17:02,04 --> 01:17:07,88
destroyed I mean I don't know not yet but
my roots are large and they've been cut

990
01:17:08,26 --> 01:17:11,62
so I'm not happy with the trees my survive

991
01:17:11,63 --> 01:17:18,60
a year or two in the business you
could. Be responsible taking them down

992
01:17:18,61 --> 01:17:24,27
it's very expensive and I don't feel that
it's my responsibility. To pay for it

993
01:17:24,28 --> 01:17:28,85
because the buffer is
being destroyed so work.

994
01:17:32,59 --> 01:17:39,12
By way of discussion with the developer
or. You know the builder builder of that

995
01:17:39,25 --> 01:17:43,28
project Tony is you know I've been in
communication with you know the town offices

996
01:17:43,29 --> 01:17:49,06
and with Michael and Sam. Unfortunately
contacts kind of drifted since the

997
01:17:49,07 --> 01:17:53,87
beginning of the year we were set to have
many scheduled meetings that have either

998
01:17:54,21 --> 01:17:59,77
gone by the wayside or haven't been handed
to them with Michael specifically and we

999
01:17:59,78 --> 01:18:03,82
like Sando about it we were supposed to
meet tomorrow however Michael did reach out

1000
01:18:04,45 --> 01:18:10,00
and unfortunately so we're going to postpone
that maybe until next week I will be

1001
01:18:10,01 --> 01:18:15,88
bringing up how these points to them however.
Are in India launch just so happened

1002
01:18:15,88 --> 01:18:20,99
. You know I made you aware that
we're also on my property having

1003
01:18:21,00 --> 01:18:26,66
a lot of issues just so the town birds you
know aware of this when they were going

1004
01:18:26,67 --> 01:18:31,44
through the construction and. I guess
building what is considered to be face to

1005
01:18:32,07 --> 01:18:32,62
they pushed

1006
01:18:32,66 --> 01:18:38,28
a lot of subsoil onto our property are
guesstimates some are an axis of about

1007
01:18:38,33 --> 01:18:43,99
thirty thousand cubic yards. All done without
your permission without my permission

1008
01:18:44,11 --> 01:18:50,05
so that was not agreed upon that was never
agreed upon that was done OK so I would

1009
01:18:50,24 --> 01:18:56,11
very much like to go on the record with
that all right. So with that they also cut

1010
01:18:56,15 --> 01:19:02,24
into not only the buffer zone but part of
the wetland. They were putting up some so

1011
01:19:02,28 --> 01:19:06,28
Francine I like to guys know that number
one you're not supposed to be on our

1012
01:19:06,29 --> 01:19:10,65
property number two you're going
right through a New York State D.C.

1013
01:19:10,66 --> 01:19:17,57
Wetland and they said we're doing what
we're told to be told to do and so we've

1014
01:19:17,58 --> 01:19:23,03
asked by home this is one of four contractors
they were doing what Michael and

1015
01:19:23,44 --> 01:19:28,80
Michael Campbell County who is with the
rise of division I'm not sure what they

1016
01:19:28,81 --> 01:19:34,49
call their group by and then they were doing
what Franco Frattini from one to four

1017
01:19:34,50 --> 01:19:38,50
was telling them Frank was not
there this time so I brought out

1018
01:19:38,51 --> 01:19:41,77
a map showed him they were going right
through it they said we have to get this and

1019
01:19:42,34 --> 01:19:48,37
and yes the restrain Yes You know none of
it was seeded so there were some problems

1020
01:19:48,95 --> 01:19:52,62
and I said Buck if you need guys need to
get the same get it in but you're on my

1021
01:19:52,63 --> 01:19:56,89
property and I don't want this happening
but I also don't want silt going into

1022
01:19:56,90 --> 01:20:02,53
wetlands so of course I called Michael and
I've been trying to work this out with

1023
01:20:02,54 --> 01:20:07,49
him to not include the town even though
I've been in the town now and it's just

1024
01:20:07,50 --> 01:20:11,21
resulted in nothing to the point now
where we're going into it's almost

1025
01:20:11,22 --> 01:20:17,49
a year. We're going into the spring.
Everybody in Penfield would like me to clean

1026
01:20:17,50 --> 01:20:21,67
up my property and get it going and we're
finally to the stage of where we can but

1027
01:20:21,68 --> 01:20:27,87
now are creating an elevation is so high
that I'm not able to achieve the site plan

1028
01:20:28,18 --> 01:20:29,64
that we you know brought forth

1029
01:20:29,65 --> 01:20:34,63
a couple of years ago I believe it was Jim
And so we're really getting landlocked

1030
01:20:35,32 --> 01:20:41,13
by this development first it was in the
sewers now it's this excavation in phase

1031
01:20:41,14 --> 01:20:48,07
two and so we're hoping that we can come
to resolution but I I don't know if

1032
01:20:48,08 --> 01:20:51,61
it's going to happen for the spring and
here we are we're going to be stuck again

1033
01:20:51,66 --> 01:20:55,48
and some of the neighbors are being affected
in other ways than I am and they're

1034
01:20:55,49 --> 01:21:01,21
coming to me so I at least want to make
the town board aware of this and it's my

1035
01:21:01,22 --> 01:21:06,25
understanding that the town board has
approved to stop any construction Jason to

1036
01:21:06,26 --> 01:21:11,21
lease my property value would probably
want the same until they fix or trees or

1037
01:21:11,22 --> 01:21:15,41
what have you. Which we might need
some more discussions for I completely

1038
01:21:15,42 --> 01:21:20,03
understand but at least it's nowhere to
let you guys know we are having hardship

1039
01:21:20,04 --> 01:21:22,78
with us and there's

1040
01:21:22,79 --> 01:21:27,47
a few points that are brought up to jam
into job. Number one I don't want to see

1041
01:21:27,48 --> 01:21:29,20
coming over and the C.B.S.

1042
01:21:29,21 --> 01:21:34,90
Cuts and fills in the wetlands and in the
buffer zone and then everybody to be on

1043
01:21:34,91 --> 01:21:38,03
hold and to have just a
problem with the way the D.C.

1044
01:21:38,14 --> 01:21:40,70
Which is going it's a
matter of time. It's not

1045
01:21:40,71 --> 01:21:44,48
a matter of at and especially if they're
going to inspect this pond that's being

1046
01:21:44,49 --> 01:21:49,52
created. They might just when the right
over the property is what else is going on

1047
01:21:49,57 --> 01:21:50,55
and yes there is still

1048
01:21:50,56 --> 01:21:54,85
a fence that's broken yes there is silt
it's going into one land yes there is oil

1049
01:21:54,89 --> 01:22:00,67
runoff from the construction I have pictures
of all this so as much as I've been

1050
01:22:00,68 --> 01:22:05,48
know to find them there still are actions
that are being done there's promises but

1051
01:22:05,49 --> 01:22:09,66
nothing is actually happening and I
understand in the middle of winter but I'm

1052
01:22:09,67 --> 01:22:10,73
trying to get some sort of

1053
01:22:10,74 --> 01:22:16,16
a formulated agreed upon plan of at
least what the actual ride subdivision

1054
01:22:16,17 --> 01:22:23,11
Cavalcanti Japan you go to moving forward
so we can mitigate minimize and move

1055
01:22:23,12 --> 01:22:29,19
on to what we have here. Currently any
litigation going on you know around this you

1056
01:22:29,20 --> 01:22:36,11
know this talks we are trying like
hell to get this fixed before. You

1057
01:22:36,12 --> 01:22:40,00
know we get pushed to the envelope because
the statute of limitations is one year

1058
01:22:40,60 --> 01:22:46,17
from when they enter the property into
the trust us. So we're coming up on that

1059
01:22:46,23 --> 01:22:51,33
verse three. So I know that you know I'm
working with under Bergen caster through

1060
01:22:51,34 --> 01:22:58,32
the corporation and. We're trying to
not get to that stage so in our talk

1061
01:22:58,33 --> 01:23:03,27
next week we're going to bring up the point
that this anniversary is coming up and

1062
01:23:03,28 --> 01:23:09,68
what can we do to avoid
this so but. You know.

1063
01:23:10,69 --> 01:23:17,64
It's not only. Me with next week I mean
with Michael with caustic engineering.

1064
01:23:18,99 --> 01:23:23,87
And with David Kang from undergoing
counseling hoping that we can find

1065
01:23:23,88 --> 01:23:29,98
a resolution to remove this oil they have
been coming up with proposals to kind of

1066
01:23:30,19 --> 01:23:33,38
slope the soil however we're making

1067
01:23:33,39 --> 01:23:38,41
a nursery garden retail center we're going
to be growing plants and you can't grow

1068
01:23:38,42 --> 01:23:41,99
plants and it's steep slope it's not going
to work you're going to have crooked

1069
01:23:41,100 --> 01:23:45,69
plants I don't think anybody wants us not
to mention the fact that you're healthy

1070
01:23:46,13 --> 01:23:52,52
had somebody. Different type right you
know it's not exactly what we're going for

1071
01:23:52,97 --> 01:23:59,84
so OK And so I just want to
I just want to. So as as

1072
01:23:59,85 --> 01:24:06,43
this work was being done. On
private property your property.

1073
01:24:07,89 --> 01:24:14,34
With your approval. You did Tom
to stop and. You know damn the

1074
01:24:14,35 --> 01:24:20,08
torpedoes so to speak and kept on doing
what really major disconnect when you

1075
01:24:20,09 --> 01:24:21,57
pretty much have a noun had there's been

1076
01:24:21,58 --> 01:24:27,11
a major disconnect where I never approved
it Michael for just kind of told them to

1077
01:24:27,12 --> 01:24:30,84
start going and I'm now dealing with Frank

1078
01:24:30,85 --> 01:24:35,92
a funny from one of four who is following
the lead from Michael Cavalcanti Michael

1079
01:24:35,93 --> 01:24:42,46
one calling and saying Stop stop stop
Frank's telling his guys to go. And I'm

1080
01:24:42,47 --> 01:24:45,59
trying to tell them that they're coming
on the property and you're not welcome to

1081
01:24:45,60 --> 01:24:51,12
not push any of the soil and yet here they
are still doing it Michael had handed me

1082
01:24:51,59 --> 01:24:57,03
a agreement at one point that Jeff I believe
you have in your files. That Michael

1083
01:24:57,04 --> 01:25:02,88
handed to me not only did I not sign it
but Michael didn't sign it either. It was

1084
01:25:02,89 --> 01:25:09,21
never agreed upon from either one of us so
here we are and this is all done and we

1085
01:25:09,22 --> 01:25:09,42
have

1086
01:25:09,43 --> 01:25:17,84
a big. There is water from this neighborhood
going into my back building. One

1087
01:25:17,85 --> 01:25:22,59
of the doors actually the framing it's
all rotted out from all the water that's

1088
01:25:22,60 --> 01:25:27,58
been standing there so I'm concerned about
this and we could have some issues going

1089
01:25:27,59 --> 01:25:29,76
forward if this doesn't get fixed that's

1090
01:25:29,77 --> 01:25:33,78
a match and it's going to stop the business
all the plans that have promised agenda

1091
01:25:34,39 --> 01:25:39,91
in the building department I can't honor
until this is worked out and I like to be

1092
01:25:39,92 --> 01:25:46,86
and I read if we can get this going and
we get things. Just can you give me your

1093
01:25:46,87 --> 01:25:53,39
property address. Again minus twenty
six Fox OK I was going as much

1094
01:25:53,93 --> 01:25:58,11
think it's right behind the cul de sac
behind you yeah twenty three forty three

1095
01:25:58,12 --> 01:26:02,08
hundred OK. Thank you.

1096
01:26:06,78 --> 01:26:12,65
And it's your plan after you meet.
With the attorney kind of rocky and.

1097
01:26:14,29 --> 01:26:20,30
Then to share that back with the town
staff story where you are with that

1098
01:26:21,07 --> 01:26:23,85
yeah we certainly well just to clarify

1099
01:26:24,36 --> 01:26:31,18
a front you will not be there it's David
Brock I think accosted. KASICH OK yes you

1100
01:26:31,48 --> 01:26:36,71
did say that you said Kasich
Cavalcanti. You're yourself.

1101
01:26:38,96 --> 01:26:41,29
Frank however he does not want to be

1102
01:26:41,30 --> 01:26:45,96
a part of this OK he said he's very much
opposed to coming from my understanding

1103
01:26:46,54 --> 01:26:53,43
invited a few so I have been keeping the
town involved in this I think if not

1104
01:26:53,44 --> 01:26:58,95
a little too much sometimes but at any
rate you know I will continue that so they

1105
01:26:58,96 --> 01:26:59,49
are C.C.

1106
01:26:59,50 --> 01:27:05,51
Donnelly emails and I think since the day
that this started. I was you know I made

1107
01:27:05,52 --> 01:27:09,87
the town aware that there were wetland
cuts in Phil's going on without

1108
01:27:09,88 --> 01:27:15,03
a true. Because I knew the consequences
of what can come of this and.

1109
01:27:16,87 --> 01:27:22,90
You know hindsight should have had the
police involved sure however this was we had

1110
01:27:22,97 --> 01:27:27,39
partnership agreements on the
topsoil portion so I thought we had

1111
01:27:27,40 --> 01:27:32,56
a better relationship than what we did
shame on our partnership with Cavalcanti

1112
01:27:32,83 --> 01:27:37,73
Caracas for the top so rights for the tops
having to do nothing with this Phil soil

1113
01:27:37,84 --> 01:27:41,33
and I've had excavation companies
come over and give us for

1114
01:27:41,34 --> 01:27:45,14
a nasty mess as to how much it's going
to cost yet they say they want to try to

1115
01:27:45,15 --> 01:27:50,40
take care of it themselves but the clock's
ticking and the springs come in and

1116
01:27:50,44 --> 01:27:54,73
we're trying to open for business you know
we have construction we need to complete

1117
01:27:54,77 --> 01:27:55,18
and you get

1118
01:27:55,19 --> 01:28:01,77
a retail greenhouse in the back. Are
kind of stuck with plants so stuff OK

1119
01:28:02,10 --> 01:28:02,30
it's

1120
01:28:02,31 --> 01:28:07,28
a tough going here. All right well we
appreciate the update certainly will we'll

1121
01:28:07,29 --> 01:28:13,27
stay close with Mr Costello
and staff on this and.

1122
01:28:14,76 --> 01:28:19,64
And I would just ask that you provide an
update from that session you're having

1123
01:28:19,65 --> 01:28:24,89
next week back to back into
the into the town staff. But

1124
01:28:24,90 --> 01:28:30,30
a good idea to be whatever we come up with
maybe to now the next work session that

1125
01:28:30,31 --> 01:28:35,75
the town board has for the following morning.
Let's see what let's see what happens

1126
01:28:35,76 --> 01:28:41,21
I mean certainly. You know we'll keep this
kind of as an active item but let's see

1127
01:28:41,22 --> 01:28:46,19
what comes out of this obviously if
this gets into a civil matter into

1128
01:28:46,20 --> 01:28:53,12
a civil suit. Then that is obviously
something between yourself and Mr Cavalcanti

1129
01:28:53,13 --> 01:28:59,31
or true party or what have you but let's
see what shakes out here next week I'm I

1130
01:28:59,32 --> 01:29:02,67
mean I'm hoping that everybody can come to

1131
01:29:02,68 --> 01:29:06,86
a in agreement and certainly
you know we have to take

1132
01:29:06,87 --> 01:29:13,12
a look at the tree damage as well as
as part of that and what can be done

1133
01:29:13,73 --> 01:29:17,33
to address that matter as well we all I
read it you know up with traffic he's going

1134
01:29:17,34 --> 01:29:20,89
to step over tomorrow just to kind of
see what the swelling it's in the back

1135
01:29:20,90 --> 01:29:26,90
because straight from the road it just
points right directly to his callous not

1136
01:29:26,91 --> 01:29:32,05
just property could be an issue I'm just
worried about drainage we have no water

1137
01:29:32,06 --> 01:29:38,53
going to go out land you don't need any
more OK All right good very good thank you

1138
01:29:38,77 --> 01:29:44,22
thank you thank you very
much. OK let's see we saw

1139
01:29:44,23 --> 01:29:49,35
a few folks in the audience I think Ed was
the next one op ed it's almost Pascha

1140
01:29:49,36 --> 01:29:56,28
bedtime. Better because maybe you could

1141
01:29:56,72 --> 01:30:03,12
maybe you could take out the whole cause
if you need to continue on with that. And

1142
01:30:03,13 --> 01:30:06,45
we're going to get to. Cover station with

1143
01:30:06,46 --> 01:30:11,51
a little less later. My issue involves

1144
01:30:11,52 --> 01:30:13,52
a little eight legged creature called

1145
01:30:13,53 --> 01:30:20,46
a deer tick. And I wasn't there to
specifically concerned about them until my dog

1146
01:30:20,47 --> 01:30:21,65
started picking them up

1147
01:30:21,66 --> 01:30:25,38
a couple of years ago on school property
and used to walk my dog on school property

1148
01:30:25,39 --> 01:30:31,63
guillotine. I don't walk anymore so I
don't know any of that problem I went to

1149
01:30:32,72 --> 01:30:33,35
a P.T.A.

1150
01:30:33,36 --> 01:30:38,50
Meeting and talked to the principal and she
was concerned she got and buildings and

1151
01:30:38,51 --> 01:30:43,67
grounds and requested them to do some
cleanup along the west property line of

1152
01:30:43,68 --> 01:30:49,60
behind the parking lot and behind Fanny
which is that which is school district

1153
01:30:49,61 --> 01:30:53,74
preparatory to where the range it seems
you little creatures like to sit in

1154
01:30:53,75 --> 01:30:58,86
telegraphs no way for the deer to come by
the deer or their homes for reproduction

1155
01:30:59,57 --> 01:31:00,47
I didn't think it was

1156
01:31:00,48 --> 01:31:05,08
a problem with Lyme disease in Penfield
until I was talking to this or interim

1157
01:31:05,09 --> 01:31:08,38
superintendent of schools who said
it was affected his family in

1158
01:31:08,39 --> 01:31:11,62
a pick it up and Penfield.
It looks like we've got

1159
01:31:11,63 --> 01:31:16,71
a problem here with deer and deer ticks
and I was hoping that you could use your

1160
01:31:16,72 --> 01:31:17,31
column as

1161
01:31:17,32 --> 01:31:22,85
a kind of information thing to get the
word out to the public to see if we can't

1162
01:31:23,00 --> 01:31:25,75
move the deer back into
the woods I did have

1163
01:31:25,76 --> 01:31:31,34
a problem in my area until one lady deer
decided to raise her kids intently and

1164
01:31:31,35 --> 01:31:37,54
next door for ten years. And. Limit the.

1165
01:31:38,47 --> 01:31:40,86
Growth we have around her
houses do things that get

1166
01:31:40,87 --> 01:31:45,09
a deer don't like to eat maybe get the
deer out of the subdivisions and get them

1167
01:31:45,10 --> 01:31:51,78
back into the woods
really. OK. In an item on

1168
01:31:51,96 --> 01:31:58,86
deer ticks so I'll probably read about
my reference was to round to explore the

1169
01:31:59,28 --> 01:32:03,89
January February issue. That I was
reading and they were talking about the

1170
01:32:03,90 --> 01:32:07,78
expansion of Lyme disease in the Champlain
Valley and into the Adirondacks which

1171
01:32:07,79 --> 01:32:11,92
they thought was immune from Lyme disease
but like because each is spreading across

1172
01:32:11,93 --> 01:32:14,100
the state so look look
looks like we've got

1173
01:32:15,01 --> 01:32:21,89
a potential problem. OK you can
reach out to our friends from

1174
01:32:21,90 --> 01:32:27,10
D.C. As well as. Because.
I know they've got

1175
01:32:27,11 --> 01:32:32,55
a lot of information that they might be
able to make reference to we can take those

1176
01:32:32,63 --> 01:32:33,70
brochures or maybe

1177
01:32:33,71 --> 01:32:40,29
a hotlink and put that right on the website
so folks can click on that as well OK

1178
01:32:41,27 --> 01:32:46,35
thanks Ed anyone else that would like to
address the board on any matter Good to

1179
01:32:46,36 --> 01:32:51,74
see you sir. All right we'll move move on
there's another opportunity at the end of

1180
01:32:51,75 --> 01:32:57,71
the agenda and I will move on. Now
additions and deletions to the agenda.

1181
01:32:59,18 --> 01:33:04,71
Scene we have the minutes of December
seventeenth two thousand and fourteen before

1182
01:33:04,72 --> 01:33:07,39
us. Excuse not entertain

1183
01:33:07,40 --> 01:33:14,39
a motion of approval for those
minutes. For seven. Second who've

1184
01:33:14,40 --> 01:33:18,60
been seconded and a discussion
see no discussion I'd ask for

1185
01:33:18,61 --> 01:33:24,90
a roll call vote place. That's
right more I claim I live.

1186
01:33:26,17 --> 01:33:30,65
Petition so snowboard Town Clerk town
attorney received any petitions his her last

1187
01:33:30,66 --> 01:33:35,55
get together seen on move on to resolution
by function starting with line finance

1188
01:33:35,56 --> 01:33:40,43
police establishment of the way bridge
court subdivision special approve meant

1189
01:33:40,44 --> 01:33:45,42
district move second Prezza public hearing
was held on December seventeenth two

1190
01:33:45,43 --> 01:33:49,61
thousand and fourteen to consider the
petition and hear all persons interested in

1191
01:33:49,62 --> 01:33:54,92
the establishment of the way Bridgeport
subdivision it fourteen sixty nine Jackson

1192
01:33:54,93 --> 01:34:00,22
Road where the town board received no
negative or substantial employ regarding this

1193
01:34:00,23 --> 01:34:01,89
matter Now therefore be

1194
01:34:01,90 --> 01:34:07,30
a result of that the annexed order be
executed by the town supervisor and members

1195
01:34:07,31 --> 01:34:11,47
of the town board to establish the
weighbridge court subdivision special

1196
01:34:11,48 --> 01:34:16,93
Improvement District thank you thank you
the more I think before you go to. Like

1197
01:34:16,94 --> 01:34:21,54
them because yes you do
and if you would. Hire

1198
01:34:21,55 --> 01:34:28,07
a good middle man to use the word special.
In the title of the resolution in the

1199
01:34:28,08 --> 01:34:30,29
value of the road so it will be

1200
01:34:30,30 --> 01:34:37,18
a special. OK. Mr Moore
regime maker would you

1201
01:34:37,85 --> 01:34:42,44
make that motion Yes I will make the motion
to add that language to the resolution

1202
01:34:42,45 --> 01:34:47,68
both in the title and in the body of
the resolution as per their counsel's

1203
01:34:47,69 --> 01:34:52,82
recommendation he says is going to
thank you very much OK So call for

1204
01:34:52,83 --> 01:34:59,12
a vote on the amendment and we will go to
the main the main motion so this vote is

1205
01:34:59,13 --> 01:35:05,21
for the amendment adding the word part to
not only the name of the resolution but

1206
01:35:05,22 --> 01:35:07,53
also the body the
resolution then I'd ask for

1207
01:35:07,68 --> 01:35:13,71
a roll call vote call the
fountain Metzler more quit

1208
01:35:14,58 --> 01:35:20,31
five thank you and now for the main
motion any discussion on this particular

1209
01:35:20,32 --> 01:35:26,34
resolution. OK scene and then this will
will be for the amended resolution.

1210
01:35:27,41 --> 01:35:34,12
Called The Fountain I I
more plan I. Thank you.

1211
01:35:35,52 --> 01:35:39,86
Establishment of the stench in number
fifty seven to the Pentagon consolidated

1212
01:35:39,87 --> 01:35:46,60
sanitary sewer district Weybridge court
subdivision fourteen sixteen I just. Moved

1213
01:35:46,77 --> 01:35:51,05
second whereas public hearing was held
at Penn field town hall and December

1214
01:35:51,06 --> 01:35:54,65
seventeenth two thousand and
fourteen at seven thirty P.M.

1215
01:35:54,69 --> 01:35:59,19
To consider the petition and hear all
persons interested in the establishment of

1216
01:35:59,20 --> 01:36:04,72
extension number fifty seven to the
Penfield consolidated sanity sanitary sewer

1217
01:36:04,73 --> 01:36:09,29
district Weybridge court subdivision where
the town board received no negative

1218
01:36:09,68 --> 01:36:14,68
comments were got related to this matter
whereas the said cost of the sewer

1219
01:36:14,69 --> 01:36:20,64
district improvements shall be borne soley
by the property owners and developer Now

1220
01:36:20,65 --> 01:36:25,37
therefore be it Resolved That the next
order be executed by the supervisor and

1221
01:36:25,38 --> 01:36:30,34
members of the Penfield town board to
establish the extension fifty seven to the

1222
01:36:30,35 --> 01:36:36,12
Penfield consolidated sanitary sewer
destroyed. Weybridge subdivision thank you

1223
01:36:36,73 --> 01:36:41,78
thank you Mr Moore no discussion of this
resolution. See no discussion roll call

1224
01:36:41,79 --> 01:36:47,91
vote please call I thought. I. Plan I.

1225
01:36:49,71 --> 01:36:56,04
Authors nation from re subdivision of
plans in the action. To subdivision move

1226
01:36:56,18 --> 01:37:00,64
second where the developer of the Ashland
Rice subdivision proposed to construct

1227
01:37:00,65 --> 01:37:04,100
a seam Terry sewer from phase two of the
subdivision north through the property

1228
01:37:05,01 --> 01:37:10,39
located at twenty three forty three Penfield
road to an existing sanitary sewer and

1229
01:37:10,40 --> 01:37:15,54
Dublin Road to service said phase of
development in offered lands to the town of

1230
01:37:15,55 --> 01:37:22,18
Penfield to allow it to maintain said sewer
whereas subsequent to Ashlyn rise phase

1231
01:37:22,19 --> 01:37:26,82
two subdivision plat being recorded the
by row county clerk's office on March

1232
01:37:26,83 --> 01:37:31,83
thirty first two thousand and fourteen in
Library three four seven of the maps the

1233
01:37:31,84 --> 01:37:36,28
developer devised an alternative route
to service phase two of the subdivision

1234
01:37:36,61 --> 01:37:40,57
resulting in the town no longer needing
the lands previously offered by the

1235
01:37:40,58 --> 01:37:45,91
developer is sewer maintenance and sewer
maintenance was no longer necessary at

1236
01:37:45,92 --> 01:37:50,92
that location whereas the developer now
proposes to re subdivided those lands

1237
01:37:50,93 --> 01:37:57,89
offered to the town into the adjacent lot
to fifteen to sixteen into seventeen of

1238
01:37:57,90 --> 01:38:03,77
the actual Rice phase two subdivision where
is town staff and board is supportive

1239
01:38:03,78 --> 01:38:07,32
of the applicant's proposal
to resubmit re sub devise

1240
01:38:07,33 --> 01:38:12,91
a lats to give them greater area in additional
buffer from twenty three forty three

1241
01:38:12,92 --> 01:38:17,01
Penfield road Now therefore be it Resolved
That the town board of the town of

1242
01:38:17,02 --> 01:38:23,10
Penfield hereby declines the offer of
said lands and the owners of said project

1243
01:38:23,24 --> 01:38:29,18
they have the lands re subdivided into
lats to fifteen to sixteen to seventeen of

1244
01:38:29,19 --> 01:38:33,99
the actual rise phase two subdivision
and that the recent division plant be

1245
01:38:34,00 --> 01:38:39,44
prepared showing said subdivision as
proposed by developers to be signed by the

1246
01:38:39,45 --> 01:38:43,88
supervisor in recorded in
this resolution. That's

1247
01:38:43,89 --> 01:38:50,09
a lot of THANK YOU THANK YOU discussion
of this resolution see no discussion I've

1248
01:38:50,10 --> 01:38:50,40
asked for

1249
01:38:50,41 --> 01:38:57,48
a roll call vote please call
my thought I write more when I

1250
01:38:57,96 --> 01:39:03,92
arrive. At through the town board to
accept and Monroe County block grant for

1251
01:39:03,93 --> 01:39:09,39
thirty four thousand seven hundred fifty
dollars for the Empire Boulevard sidewalk

1252
01:39:09,40 --> 01:39:16,16
improvement project and execute an
agreement moved. Second time I feel as

1253
01:39:16,17 --> 01:39:20,72
a member of the manor County Community
Development Block Grant urban consortium and

1254
01:39:20,73 --> 01:39:21,87
the town has entered into

1255
01:39:21,88 --> 01:39:26,44
a cooperation agreement to participate
in the Community Development Program and

1256
01:39:26,45 --> 01:39:30,49
comply with the federal laws and requirements
regularly in the program the town of

1257
01:39:30,50 --> 01:39:35,03
Penfield after consultation with the public
has identified an appropriate use up

1258
01:39:35,04 --> 01:39:40,23
potential community development funding
in the town the town has made application

1259
01:39:40,27 --> 01:39:42,20
the money kind about ministration for

1260
01:39:42,21 --> 01:39:46,63
a project that satisfied their determination
and the men were kind about Mitt

1261
01:39:46,64 --> 01:39:48,86
administration has awarded grant for

1262
01:39:48,87 --> 01:39:53,50
a maximum amount of thirty four thousand
seven hundred fifty dollars for the Empire

1263
01:39:53,69 --> 01:39:58,87
Boulevard sidewalk improvement project in
the town of Penfield the town of Penfield

1264
01:39:58,88 --> 01:40:03,10
is deemed in the best interest of the town
to accept this grant Now therefore be

1265
01:40:03,11 --> 01:40:07,85
a result of the town board accept this
grant and encourages the implementation of

1266
01:40:07,86 --> 01:40:09,45
this project and then for

1267
01:40:09,46 --> 01:40:14,09
a bit further result at the time
of pedophile supervisor found B.

1268
01:40:14,13 --> 01:40:18,10
And is here by authorized to execute an
agreement with Monroe County where the

1269
01:40:18,11 --> 01:40:22,85
project and the Grant thank
you and a discussion of

1270
01:40:22,86 --> 01:40:26,64
a ship frozen real quickly I would just
like to think your efforts and the efforts

1271
01:40:26,65 --> 01:40:32,48
of both our county legislators here in the
town of Penfield draw in Dan Quatro from

1272
01:40:32,49 --> 01:40:35,84
legislative districts nine
and fifteen I know for

1273
01:40:35,85 --> 01:40:40,59
a fact that the town of Penfield competes
with other towns and other municipalities

1274
01:40:40,82 --> 01:40:46,14
in Monroe County for certain lots some with
money every year and we seem to be very

1275
01:40:46,15 --> 01:40:51,76
successful in competing for it as per this
resolution for the thirty four thousand

1276
01:40:51,77 --> 01:40:54,32
seven hundred fifty
dollars so there's always

1277
01:40:54,33 --> 01:40:59,62
a possibility that we would get zero or we
would get less and I'd like to thank you

1278
01:40:59,63 --> 01:41:03,81
on behalf of this board for your efforts
and the county legislators afeard in

1279
01:41:03,82 --> 01:41:05,25
securing this funding through

1280
01:41:05,26 --> 01:41:12,03
a competitive process thank you thank
you. OK see no further discussion of

1281
01:41:12,04 --> 01:41:18,97
ass or wrong place called The
Fountain Metzler I more when I

1282
01:41:19,27 --> 01:41:22,02
drive. Authorisation to attend

1283
01:41:22,03 --> 01:41:27,57
a highway superintendent Advocacy Day for
local roads and bridges in Albany New

1284
01:41:27,58 --> 01:41:33,09
York. The New York State Association of
town and highway superintendents and the

1285
01:41:33,10 --> 01:41:38,01
New York State Association of County Highway
superintendents co-sponsor an advocacy

1286
01:41:38,02 --> 01:41:43,06
day campaign in Albany to advocate for
an increased share of the transportation

1287
01:41:43,07 --> 01:41:48,48
funding for local roads and bridges and
whereas the Advocacy Day campaigns have

1288
01:41:48,49 --> 01:41:53,30
been very successful in the past advocating
for maintaining our fair share of local

1289
01:41:53,31 --> 01:41:55,73
roads and bridges funding therefore be

1290
01:41:55,74 --> 01:42:00,43
a result of the Director of Public Works
is authorized to attend Advocacy Day

1291
01:42:00,44 --> 01:42:02,95
campaign for local roads
and bridges in Auburn

1292
01:42:02,96 --> 01:42:07,74
a march through the end for two thousand
and fifteen and that reasonable expenses

1293
01:42:07,75 --> 01:42:14,04
will be reimbursed which are budgeted in
the two thousand and fifteen budget. Thank

1294
01:42:14,05 --> 01:42:19,04
you discussion I would just offer
Mr Supervisor that this is

1295
01:42:19,05 --> 01:42:24,93
a annual event that highway superintendent
will attend along with others that show

1296
01:42:24,94 --> 01:42:31,28
up in Albany to certainly make our voices
heard with respect to fair share for

1297
01:42:31,29 --> 01:42:32,41
funding there's been

1298
01:42:32,42 --> 01:42:37,96
a lot of talk recently regarding our
area and upstate in western New York in

1299
01:42:38,00 --> 01:42:42,87
particular also not receiving their fair
share having to compete for their fair

1300
01:42:42,88 --> 01:42:47,95
share of tax dollars and this is
one way that annually we can send

1301
01:42:47,96 --> 01:42:54,19
a personal representative to advocate and
we have been successful in the past when

1302
01:42:54,20 --> 01:43:00,21
the higher superintendent band together and
show up in Albany to express the wishes

1303
01:43:00,22 --> 01:43:06,69
of the OK oldies here. So not only did
we keep our funny from last year we

1304
01:43:07,01 --> 01:43:13,40
did get additional. I would like to think
that it was really recognized by Albany

1305
01:43:13,85 --> 01:43:17,84
because of need and not because it was
an election year so I'm going to stand

1306
01:43:18,21 --> 01:43:24,32
cautiously optimistic that we'll see some
additional funding for roads highways and

1307
01:43:24,33 --> 01:43:29,91
bridges again this year OK see no
additional comments I asked her. Place.

1308
01:43:33,27 --> 01:43:39,69
More. Five. To extend contract with the

1309
01:43:39,96 --> 01:43:45,30
greater Rochester chapter of the American
Red Cross to store one disaster equipment

1310
01:43:45,31 --> 01:43:51,00
trailer at sixteen zero zero seven Jackson
Road second the town of Penfield in the

1311
01:43:51,01 --> 01:43:55,42
greater chapter of the American Red Cross
enter into an agreement to extend the two

1312
01:43:55,43 --> 01:44:00,15
thousand and fourteen current contract one
year two thousand and fifteen to store

1313
01:44:00,16 --> 01:44:04,75
one disaster trailer doesn't add to the
support of the residents in the town of

1314
01:44:04,76 --> 01:44:08,27
Penfield and the northeast side
of Monroe County and therefore be

1315
01:44:08,28 --> 01:44:11,13
a result of the Director of Public
Works is authorized to sign

1316
01:44:11,14 --> 01:44:14,94
a one year extension for the two thousand
and fifteen year with the greater

1317
01:44:14,95 --> 01:44:19,44
Rochester chapter of the
American Red Cross. Discussion.

1318
01:44:21,38 --> 01:44:27,24
Discussion place. The
fountain Metzler more.

1319
01:44:30,68 --> 01:44:33,45
Authorization to extend
two thousand and fourteen

1320
01:44:33,49 --> 01:44:39,58
a mandatory agreement all seasons county
and town agreement moved jacket the result

1321
01:44:39,59 --> 01:44:42,42
by the cement of the supervisors
authorized to execute

1322
01:44:42,43 --> 01:44:44,73
a one year extension to the
two thousand and fourteen

1323
01:44:44,74 --> 01:44:50,93
a mandatory All Seasons county town
work agreement. Thank you discussion.

1324
01:44:52,18 --> 01:44:57,17
See no discussion of Roll Call. I. Write.

1325
01:44:59,27 --> 01:45:05,98
Five guys advertising for bids for
printing program so much so I can be

1326
01:45:05,99 --> 01:45:10,63
a director of recreation is he right
authorized to ever ties in the manner

1327
01:45:10,64 --> 01:45:15,95
prescribed by law for Seal proposals to
furnish the town for the following printing

1328
01:45:15,96 --> 01:45:20,45
of the recreation department seasonal
program brochure be it Resolved That the

1329
01:45:20,46 --> 01:45:24,83
service is covered by such seal proposals
is in accordance with specifications

1330
01:45:24,84 --> 01:45:29,78
prepared by the director of recreation
proposals are to be submitted to the office

1331
01:45:29,79 --> 01:45:31,88
of the town clerk until eleven A.M.

1332
01:45:31,92 --> 01:45:35,83
February eleventh two thousand and fifteen
and then and there be opened and read

1333
01:45:35,84 --> 01:45:41,97
publicly thank YOU discussion. Place.

1334
01:45:43,03 --> 01:45:49,52
The fountain. More.
Five. Authorization for

1335
01:45:49,53 --> 01:45:56,51
supervisor recreation contacts.
This resolution authorizing the

1336
01:45:56,52 --> 01:46:01,43
town supervisor sign thirty three recreation
Kyra tracks thirty three there all the

1337
01:46:01,44 --> 01:46:06,36
different programs that are going to be
taking place for recreation department in

1338
01:46:06,37 --> 01:46:11,80
our summer or summer spring brochure.
Winter Spring and the programs continue to

1339
01:46:11,81 --> 01:46:17,48
grow so it's good good news for a lot
of folks and I would like to just take

1340
01:46:17,49 --> 01:46:24,14
a minute when we're talking about
contracts this board. Now several months

1341
01:46:24,15 --> 01:46:25,14
ago made

1342
01:46:25,15 --> 01:46:31,87
a recommendation that. In our recreation
department work very closely with

1343
01:46:31,97 --> 01:46:38,55
providing some additional support and
programs for you know park day schools

1344
01:46:38,90 --> 01:46:45,61
and other activities and happy to report
that staff really stepped up and and has

1345
01:46:45,62 --> 01:46:52,25
added to that offering help some parents
when they have some of those days that

1346
01:46:52,55 --> 01:46:55,77
they may not have to take
vacations it gives them

1347
01:46:55,78 --> 01:46:58,60
a place to bring their children in

1348
01:46:58,61 --> 01:47:03,79
a safe environment some great
programming and so that was

1349
01:47:03,80 --> 01:47:09,94
a great great recommendation by the board
and I like to recognize you for that and

1350
01:47:10,06 --> 01:47:14,18
the fact that we're going to can look to
continue to grow that to help the families

1351
01:47:14,22 --> 01:47:19,90
of Penfield those of those families that
have children both working parents and try

1352
01:47:19,91 --> 01:47:24,62
to minimize you know time that they have
to take off during these some of these

1353
01:47:24,63 --> 01:47:26,98
breaks or half days and it really is

1354
01:47:26,99 --> 01:47:31,01
a win win situation. You
know for their comments.

1355
01:47:38,49 --> 01:47:43,97
By that. Brings this to all business is
there any old has to come before the board

1356
01:47:43,98 --> 01:47:48,63
this evening scene nine Is there any new
business to come before the board this

1357
01:47:48,64 --> 01:47:53,85
evening again seen none as is our second
public participation is there anyone in

1358
01:47:53,86 --> 01:47:59,64
the audience who would like to address the
board on any matter. Ok seen in see no

1359
01:47:59,65 --> 01:48:05,84
further business to come before the board
the board meeting of January twenty first

1360
01:48:05,85 --> 01:48:10,59
two thousand and fifteen stands adjourned
thank you very much for all those that

1361
01:48:10,60 --> 01:48:13,83
participated thank you
very much to Penfield T.V.

1362
01:48:13,83 --> 01:48:13,83
.

1363
01:48:58,17 --> 01:48:58,30
You know.

1364
01:49:20,11 --> 01:49:22,42
Little. Little.