Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 000, [I]© (2005) Printed 5 February 2008 (MN M£X st y le file v2 - 2 )
The true nature of CSL-1.
Sazhin M.V. 1 , Capaccioli M. 2 ' 3 , Longo G. 3 '
Paolillo M. 3 ' 4 , Khovanskaya O.S. 1 ,
Grogin N.A. 6 , Schreier, E.J. 7 , Covone, G. 5
1 - Sternberg Astronomical Institute, Moscow State University, University pr. 13, Moscow, RUSSIA
2 - VSTceN at the OAC, INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte, via Moiariello 16, 80131, Napoli, ITALY
3 - Department of Physical Sciences, University of Napoli Federico II, via Cinthia 9, 80126 Napoli, ITALY
4 - INFN - Napoli Unit, Dept. of Physical Sciences, via Cinthia 9, 80126, Napoli, ITALY
Accepted ; Received ; in original form
C ~ ~) ' 5 - INAF - Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte, via Moiariello 16, 80131, Napoli, ITALY
6 - Dep. of Physics and Astronomy, The Johns Hopkins University, 3400 North Charles Street, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA
7 - Associated Universities Inc., Suite 730, 1400 1 6th St., Washington, DC 20036, USA
On January 12 of 2006, the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) observed the pe-
culiar double extragalactic object CSL-1, suspected to be the result of gravi-
tational lensing by a cosmic string. The high resolution image shows that the
object is actually a pair of interacting giant elliptical galaxies. In spite of the
weird similarities of the energy and light distributions and of the radial veloc-
ities of the two components, CSL-1 is not the lensing of an elliptical galaxy
by a cosmic string.
Key words: cosmic string; galaxies; general; cosmology.
1 PRE-HST OBSERVATIONS OF CSL-1
The Capodimonte-Sternberg-Lens candidate n. 1 (CSL-1; «2ooo = 12 h 23 m 30^5, (W)o
Sazhin et al
—12° 38' 57'.'0), a peculiar extragalactic object observed in the OACDF by
(20031), hereafter Paper I, appears as a double source projected onto a low density field.
The two components of the source are 1.9 arcsec apart, well resolved (i.e. extended) and,
2 Sazhin M. et al.
Figure 1. Left panel: numerical simulation of the image of an E galaxy with a de Vaucouleurs [r 1 ' 4 ] light profile, as it would
appear if lensed by a cosmic string (the situation roughly corresponds to that of CSL-1 and the noise level is that expected in
our HST observations.). Right panel: the image region surrounding CSL-1 as observed by HST. A logarithmic colorscale has
been adopted to enhance the morphological details.
when observed from the ground, show roundish and identical shapes. Low resolution spectra
look identical with a high confidential level (c.l.) and both give the same redshift of 0.46 ±
0.008. Photometry matches the properties of giant elliptical galaxies. Additional medium-
high resolution observations carried on with FORS1 at V LT in March 2005 c onfirmed the
similarity of the spectra of the two objects at a 98% c.l. ISazhin et al.l (J2005J) and showed
that the differential radial velocity is compatible with zero ±20 km s -1 .
In view of all that, already in Paper I we argued that CSL-1 could be either i) the chance
alignment of two very similar giant E galaxies at the same redshift, or ii) a gravitational
lensing phenomenon. In this second case detailed modelling shows that the properties of
CSL-1 are compatible only with the lensing of an
Cosmic st rings were first in trod uced by
literature (cf. IZeldovichl (|l980f l and IVilenkfnT (jl98jj)). Recent work has als o shown the rel
galax y by a cosmic string.
Kibble! ([19761 ) and extensively discussed in the
Davis fc Kibble
evance of cosmic strings for both fundamental physics and cosmology (cf.
(2005)) and has shown that cosmic strings could be observable, in principle, via several
effects, the most important being gravitational lensing, as we extensively discussed in the
above quoted papers.
Is CSL-1 a cosmic string? In Paper I, we suggested an experimentum crucis ((Sazhin et al
2003T ): the detection of the sharp edges at faint light levels which are expected to be generated
by a cosmic string (Fig^). This test requires high angular resolution and deep observations to
be performed with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST). In what follows we shortly summarise
the most immediate outcomes of these observations.
The true nature of CSL-1. 3
2 THE DATA
The observations were performed on January 11 2006 with the ACS camera. CSL-1 was
observed for 6 HST orbit in the F814W band (comparable to Johnson- Cousins I-band)
yelding an effective exposure time of ~ 14000 seconds. The observations were performed
adopting a 1/3 pixel dither pattern, to allow sub-pixel sampling of the HS'
ray re jection. All 6 orbits were combined through the Multidrizzle software (|Koekemoer et al
PSF and cosmic
20021 ) using a 1/2 pixel (0.025 arcsec/pixel) resampling pattern. In what follows we shortly
summarize the main results.
3 THE HST IMAGES
Figure H shows the region surrounding CSL-1 as observed by the ACS Wide Field Camera
on board of HST. The faint isophotes of the two components have different shapes, which
is incompatible with CSL-1 being a cosmic string, and the expected sharp edges are not
present. In the cosmic string scenario all morphological features of the source falling inside
the deficit angle, would be mirrored on the opposite side of the string. However in the HST
image we do not see such mirroring effect for the two components, nor for any other faint
feature which, would have fallen inside the deficit angle of the string and should have been
duplicated, e.g. the faint sources on the southern side of CSL-1 visible in the right panel of
Another test, proposed and discussed bv several au
Vilenkin. Shellar dill 994
Hnterer & Vachaspati
Sazhin et al.
), takes into account the fact that the
alignment of the background object (a galaxy) inside the deficit angle of the string is a
stochastic process determined by the area of the lensing strip and by the surface density dis-
tribution of the extragalactic objects which are laying behind the string. All objects falling
inside the narrow strip defined by the deficit angle computed along the string pattern should
be affected and, the deeper the image, the larger the number of gravitationally lensed images
to be expected.
In FigOwe present the image of the whole field, produced by stacking the 6 HST orbits.
Our careful examination of the source population around CSL-1 reveals no overdensity of
galaxy pairs with separations < 2" . The lack of such galaxy pairs in our image (aside from
CSL-1) therefore leads to a strong rejection of the cosmic string hypothesis.
For completeness we also fit the two objects with two de Vaucouleurs r 1//4 light profiles
4 Sazhin M. et al.
Figure 2. The ACS field observed by HST. CSL-1 is the double object slightly off-centered. The image is the composite of the
6 HST orbits.
and subtract the model from the original data. The residual image, presented in FigOU clearly
shows the presence of warped structures in the CSL-1 outskirts, probably tidal tails due to
the interaction between the two galaxies.
As a result of our observation, we have therefore to conclude that CSL-1 is not the lensing
of an elliptical galaxy by a cosmic string.
M.V. Sazhin acknowledges the INAF-VSTceN for hospitality and financial support, and
the financial support of RFFI grant 04-02-17288. O.S. Khovanskaya acknowledges the De-
partment of Physical Sciences of the University of Naples Federico II and the INFN-Napoli
for financial support, as well as the financial support of the grants: President of RF "YS-
1418.2005.2" and of MSU for YS. This research was partly funded by the Italian Ministry
for Instruction, University and Research, through a COFIN-2004 grant no. 2004020323.
The true nature of CSL-1.
Figure 3. The normalized residuals (residuals/model) obtained by subtracting from the HST images a model consisting of two
de Vaucouleurs light profiles.
Davis A.-C, Kibble T.W.B., 2005, jhttp:// ArXiv.org/hep-th/0505050
Hindmarsh. A., in: The Formation and Evolution of Cosmic Strings, ed. by G. Gibbons,
S.W. Hawking, and T.Vachaspathi. Cambridge Univ.Press., Cambridge, 1990.
Huterer, D., Vachaspati, T., 2003, preprint, astro-ph/0305006,
Kibble T.W.B., 1976, J.Phys.A:Math & Gen. v.9, 1387
Koekemoer, A. M., Fruchter, A. S., Hook, R., Hack, W. 2002 HST Calibration Workshop,
Sazhin, M., Longo, G., Capaccioli, M., Alcala', J.M., Silvotti, R., Covone, G., Khovanskaya,
J., Pavlov, M., Pannella, M., Radovich, M., Testa, V., 2003, MNRAS, 343, 353
Sazhin, M., Khovanskaya O., Capaccioli, M., Longo, G., Alcala', J.M., Silvotti, R., Pavlov,
M. Astronomy Letters v. 31 2, pp. 73 - 79 (2005) , |http: / / ArXiv.org/astro-ph/0406516|
Sazhin, M., Capaccioli, M., Longo, G., Paolillo M., Khovanskaya, O., 2005,
astro-ph/0506400, 17 Jun 2005; accepted in AphJ.L.
Vilenkin A., 1981, Phys.Rev.,D, 23, 852
6 Sazhin M. et al.
Vilenkin A., Shellard E.P.S, 1994, Cosmic strings and other topological defects. Cambridge
Zeldovich, Ya.B., 1980, MNRAS, 192, 663