Skip to main content

Full text of "Evolving to type Ia supernovae with long delay time"

See other formats

Evolving to type la supernovae with long delay time 

Wen-Cong Chen ^'^ and Xiang-Dong Li ^ 












Recent investigations on the delay time of type la supernovae have set useful 
constraints on the progenitors of type la supernovae. Here we have calculated 
the evolution of close binaries consisting of a white dwarf and a main- sequence 
or subgiant companion. We assume that, once Roche lobe overflow occurs a 
small fraction of the lost mass from the system forms a circumbinary disk, which 
extracts the orbital angular momentum from the system through tidal torques. 
Our calculations indicate that the existence of circumbinary disk can enhance the 
mass transfer rate and cause secular orbital shrinkage. The white dwarf can grow 
in mass efficiently to trigger type la supernovae even with relatively low-mass 
(< 2M0) donor stars. Thus this scenario suggest a new possible evolutionary 
channel to those type la supernovae with long delay time ~ 1 — 3 Gyr. 

Subject headings: stars: general — binaries: close — stars: mass loss — stars: 
evolution — circumstellar matter 

1. Introduction 

Many works have suggested that type la supernovae (SNe la) can be used as the stan- 

Riess et al. 


Perlmutter et al. 


Riess et al.ll2004j ). It is widely believed that SNe la are thermonuclear explos ions of accreting 
CO w hite dwarfs (WDs) when their masses grow beyond a critical mass ( iHoyle fc Fowlei 
19601 ). However, the nature of the progenitors and the related accretion processes have still 
remained unclear. Several possible evolutionary scenarios for SN la explo sions have been pro- 
posed so far. At present, there exist Chandrasekhar ( Ch) mass mode l (IWoosley &: Weaver 
19861 ) and sub-Chandrasekhar (sub-Ch) mass model (iNomotd Il982bl ) for the critical mass 

"'^Department of Astronomy., 

Nanjing University, Nanjing, 
^Department of Physics, Shangqiu Normal University, Henan, 476000, China 




of th e exploding WDs . Furthermore, both double degenerat e model fDDl (llben &: Tutukov 
1984 : IWeebbinkI Il984l ) and single degenerate model (SD) jNomotol (19821 have been also 
proposed as the candidates for progenitors of SNe la (for a review see [Branch et al.lll995l ). 
For the DD model, previous works indicated that the expected accretion rates may cause 
the accretion- induce d collapse (AIC) of the WDs and the formation of neutron stars instead 
of SN la explosions (INomoto fc Ibenlll985l : ISaio fc Nomotdll985l : iTimmes. Woosley fc Taam 
1994h . 

Binary evolution investigations adopting the SD/Ch scenarios obtained two types of 
progenitors of SNe la. One is close binaries with a main-seque nce or subgiant companion 
of mass ~ 2 — 3.5Mf7^ and an initial orbital p eriod of ~ 1 d ( Li fc van den Heuvell 119971 : 

Langer et al.l l2000l : iHan fc Podsiadlowskil |2004| ) . The required accretion rate for steady nu- 
clear burning onto WDs could be obtained with thermal-timescale mass transfer from the 
more massive donor stars. The other is wide binaries with a red giant of masses ~ IMf^ and 
an in itial orbital period of ~ 100 d (IHachisu. Kato fc Nomotd Il996l : iLi fc van den Heuvel 

19971 ). However, mass accretion i n these systems may be unstable due to the thermal- viscous 
instability in the accretion disks (1Cannizzdll993l ). 

The various progenitor scenarios can be tested by comparison of the expected and 
measured distribution of the time delay between the formation of the progenitor systems and 
their explosio ns. Recent high-^ supernova observations suggested the mean delay time of 
t ~ 2 -4 Gvr Jstroker et al.booi boosi : ICal-Yam fc Maojbooi Isee however Barris fc Tonrv 
20061 : iForster et al. II2006I ). However, the main-sequence li fetime of > 2Mf7^ star should be < 

1 Gyr in most of the SD/DD SNe la progenitor scenarios (IHan fc Podsiadlowskil |2004| ). and 
the mass transfer timescale ('< lOOMyr) between the components of binary can be neglected. 

This led iBelczynski et al.l ( l2005l ) to conclude that only SN la progenitors in the DD scenario 
has a characteristic delay time of ~ 3 Gyr. Therefore, if the SD/Ch scenario really works 
for (at least part of) SNe la, a progenitor system with a relatively low-mass donor star is 

Supersoft X-ra .y sources (SSS), originally discover ed by the Einstein satellite in the Large 
Magellanic Cloud (iLong. Helfand &: Grabelskvlll98l!). may be the observational evidence of 
the progenitors of SNe la (jKahabka fc van den Heuvel 1997). A steady-state nuclear burning 
model on the surface of t he accreting WD in a bina ry was used to interpreted the SSS 
CAL 83 and CAL 87 by Ivan den Heuvel et al.l (119921 ). who suggested that a near- main- 
sequence secondary star with a mass of 1.3 — 2.5M0 could provide the required accretion 
rate for steady nuclear burning via thermal-timescale mass transfer. However, the catalysmic 
variable SSS J0439.8-6809, J0537. 7-7304 and IE 0035 4-7230 have very small mass ratios 
and orbital periods (~ 3 — 4 hr) (ISpruit &: Taamll200ll . and references therein), which are 


significantly less tha n that required for a b i nary with thermal-timescale mass transfer at a 

rate ~ 10 ^ ^©yi' ^- Ivan Teeseling &: Kind (119981 ) proposed that there may exist an efficient 

mechanism (irradiation-driven mass loss) to enhance the mass transfer rates in these SSS. 

The purpose of this paper is to explore the possible progenitor systems for SNe la 
with delay times of a few Gyr in the SD/Ch mo del. Enlightened by the original works of 
Spruit fc TaamI (120011 ) and iTaam fc SpruitI (120011 ) . we consider the orbital angular momen- 
tum loss through the tidal interaction of binary system with a circumbinary (CB) disk during 
the mass transfer in a close binary. Our previous works indicate that the CB disk is an ef- 
ficient mechanism extr acting angular momentum from the binary system (jChen. Li fc Qian 
20061 : IChen fc Lil |2006| ) , which may enhance the mass transfer rates and help mass accumu- 
lation on the WD. The prescriptions of binary evolution calculations are described in section 
2. In section 3, we present the numerically calculated results for the evolutionary sequences 
of the WD binaries. Finally, we discuss and summarize our results in section 4. 


We consider a binary system consisting of a CO WD (of mass Mwd), and a main- 
sequence or subgiant companion (of mass Md) with solar chemical composition (X = 0.7, 
Y = 0.28, Z = 0.02). Mass transfer will occur via Roche lobe overflow of the companion due 
to nuclear expansion of the star or orbital shrinkage. We have calculated the ev olution of 
WD binarie s adoptin g an updated ver s ion of the stellar evolution code developed by lEggleton 
(1l97ll . ll972l ) (see also lHan et al.lll994l : IPols et al.lll995l ). In the calculations we take the ratio 
of the mixing length to the pressure scale height to be 2.0. We include the following mass 
loss processes and orbital angular momentum loss mechanisms during the mass exchange. 

2.1. Mass accumulation efficiency 

The key factor for the growth of the WD mass is the accumulation ratio a of the accreted 
hydrogen converted into heavier elements. Unfortunately, there are large uncertainties in es- 
timating the values of a. For the fraction qh of t he tra nsfer red mass during hydrogen bu rn- 
ing, we adopt the prescription by lHachisu et al.l (119991 ) and lHan &: Podsiadlowskil (120041 ). If 
the mass transfer rate Md is higher than a critical value Mcr, we assume that hydrogen is 
converted into helium at a rate limited to due to the strong optically thick winds from 
the WD. The critical mass transfer rate can be written as 

1.7 -X\ /Mwd 

M„ - 

5.3 X 10 




- 0.4 Moyr- 


where X is the hydrogen mass abundance of the accreted matter. Below this value, all 
hydrogen is assumed to be burned into helium, unt il the mass transfer rate becomes less 
than Mcr/8, and strong hydrogen shell flashes occur (IKovetz fc Prialniklll994l ). Thus 

-Md > Mcr, 

Mcr > -Md > Mcr/8, 

-Md < Mcr/8. 


After the gradual increase of the mass in the helium layer on the surface of the WD, helium 
ignition occu rs. A part of the envelope rn ass is expected to be blown off due to the helium- 
shell flashes ( Kato. Saio fc Hachisul 1989). For the h elium mass accumulation ratio ane, we 
adopt the prescription given by Hachisu et al. (jl999 ). 


-0.175 (logMne + 5.35)2 ^ ^ 

-7.3 < logMne < -5.9, 
1 , -5.9 < logMne < -5. 


Summarize the above prescriptions, the mass growth rate of the CO WD is Mwd = — aH^HeMd. 
The mass lost rate from the binary system can then be written as M = (1 — Q;HaHe)Md. 

2.2. Orbital angular momentum losses 

During the mass exchange in WD binaries some fraction of the transferred matter 
from the donor star may be lost from the system in various ways. For example, high ve- 
loci ty outflows were obs erved from the ultraviolet spectra of RX J0513. 9-6951 and CAL 
83 (IGansicke et al.lll998l ). Part of the lost matter may form a disk structure surround- 

ing the binary syste m rather leave the binary system (Ivan den Heuvel fc de Loord Il973 

van den Heuvellll994l ). The optical and UV spectrum of the SSS RX J0019 8+215 6 indicate 
the presence of circumbinary material (iKuduz et al.l l2002l : iHutchings et al.l 1200 ll ) . Here we 
assume that a small fraction 5 of the mass lost feeds into the CB disk surrounding the binary 
system at its inner radius r\. Tidal torques are then exerted on the CB disk via gravitational 
interaction, extracting orb ital angular momentum from the binary system fISpruit fc Taam 


20061 ) 

Taam fc Spruitll200ll ). The angular momentum loss rate via the CB disk is (jChen fc Li 







where 7^ = rj/a, t is the mass transfer time, Porb and a are the orbital per iod and the separa- 
tion of the binary, respectively. In the standard "a viscosity" prescription (jShakura &: Sunyaev 

- 5 - 

1973 ). the viscous timescale tvi at the inner edge in the CB disk is given by t^i = s^assP'^ ' 
where /3 = H-Jri, ass and Hi are the viscosity parameter and the scale height of the CB 
disk, respectively. 

In addition, we assume that the other part {1 — 6) of the lost mass M is ejected in the 
vicinity of the WD in the form of isotropic winds or outflows, carrying away the specific 
orbital angular momentum of the WD. The mass loss in the donor's wind and its effect on 
the change of orbital angular momentum are comparatively negligible. 

3. Numerical Results 

We incorporate the prescriptions in last section into the stellar evolution code, and 
calculate the evolution of WD binaries with initial parameters of the WD mass Mwd,!, donor 
mass Md^, and orbital period Porb,i- Once the WD mass Mwd grows to IAMq, we stop the 
calculation an d assume a SNe la occurred. In our calculations, we set 7 = 1.3, ass = 0.01, 

and p = 0.03 fIChen fc Lill2006f ) 

Examples of the mass transfer sequences are shown in Figs. 1 and 2. We plot the 
calculated evolutionary sequences for a system with MwD,i = O.SM©, Md,i = l.SM©, and 
-Porb,i = 1 d in Fig. 1. The sohd and dashed curves correspond to the cases of 6 = 0.01 
and 0, respectively. If no CB disk is assumed to exist, the mass transfer rate is low enough 
(~ 5 X 10"^'' — 2 X 10~^MqYt~^) that the accumulation ratio of the accreted matter a ~ 0, 
and the WD mass hardly increases. The orbital period first decreases to ~ 0.8 d, then 
increases to < 1.4 d. When we include the effect of the CB disk with 6 = 0.01, the mass 
transfer rate maintains a relatively high value in the range of ~ 3 x 10^^ — 2 x 10^"^ MqJt^^ . 
A large fraction (~ 55%) of the transferred material is accreted by the WD, making the WD 
mass grow to IAMq to trigger SNe la. Note that the binary orbit secularly shrinks until the 
orbital period Porb reaches < 0.4 d. This evolutionary sequence may represent the formation 
history of systems like IE 0035.4—7230 with narrow orbit, low-mass donor star and rapid 
mass transfer. Figure 2 shows the evolution of the donor and WD masses with time. It is 
clear that the donor star fills its Roche lobe when its age is ~ 2 Gyr for an initial donor star 
of I.5M0, much longer than the ~ 20 Myr mass transfer time. This means that it is possible 
for the SD / Ch model to have a few Gyr delay time. 

We have calculated the evolutions of a large number of WD binaries for a wide distribu- 
tion of the initial input parameters. Figure 3 summarizes the final results of our binary evo- 
lution calculations for the distributions of the progenitor systems of SNe la in the Md,i — Porb.i 
diagram. The bias and pane shading denote the distribution area of WD binaries with a 


[M J 

Fig. 1. — Evolution of the mass transfer rate M^, orbital period Porb, and WD mass Mwd 
(lower curves) for a WD binary with MwD.i = O.SMq, Md,i = 1.5Mq and Porb.i = Id. The 
solid and dashed curves denote the evolutionary tracks with 5 — 0.01 and 0, respectively. 

- 7- 

Fig. 2. — Evolution of the donor mass (solid curve) and WD mass (dashed curve) when 
MwD,i = O.8M0, Md,i = I.5M0, and Porb,i = Id. 

- 8 - 

WD of initial mass MwD,i = 1-2 and O.8M0, respectively. Beyond these two areas, SNe la 
explosions cannot occur due to either low mass accumulation rate or unstable mass transfer. 
Compared with previous investigations, our CB disk model opens a possible evolutionary 
channel to SNe la for WD binaries with relatively low initial mass donor star of ~ 1 — 2 Mq 
and hence long delay times. 

To investigate the properties of a companion star that has survived the supernova ex- 
plosion we have examined the consequences of heating and mass stripping by the impact 
of the supernova shell in a SN la on the secondaries. For the 24 (M-wD,i = O.8M0) and 
71 (MwD,i = I.2M0) WD progenitor binaries shown in Fig. 3, we c alculate the rnass los s 

fraction of the secondary star following the semianalytical method of IWheeler et al.l (Il975l ): 
the total ejected mass fraction is given by ?7ej = r/st + Ar^cv, where r/st and 77ev are the stripped 
and evaporated mass fraction respectively, A is an adjusted parameter we assume to include 
the uncertainties in estimating r]eM- Here we take the mass Msn =.l-4A f(n and the velocity 

t;sn = 8500 kms~i for the SN ejecta (IMarietta. Burrows fc Frvxelll 120001 ). and A = 0.5. We 

find that the subgiant secondary (of mass 0.3 — 2.6M0) loses ~ 9% — 28% of its mass after 
the SN. Generally the greater mass or binary separation, the smaller mass ejection fraction. 
Figure 4 shows the distribution of the secondary stars in the HR diagram just before and 
after the SN explosions. The latter could be compared with and testified by f uture obser- 

vatio ns of the companions of SNe la in young, nearby supernova remnants (e.g. ICanal et al. 


4. Discussion and Summary 

Recently iMannucci. Delia Valle fc Panagial (120061 ) , on the basis of observational argu- 
ments, suggest that there is a bimodal delay time distribution, in which about half of SNe 
la explode soon after their stellar birth, in a time ~ 10^ yr, while the remaining half have 
a much wider distribution, well described by an exponential function with a decay time 
of about 3 Gyr. In the traditional SD/Ch model the rapid mass transfer required limits 
the donor stars to be more massive than ~ 2Mq (ILi fc van den Heuvell 119971 : iLanger et al. 

2OOOI : iHan fc Podsiadlowskil I2OO4J ). The innovation in this work is taking into account the 

effect of the CB disk on the mass transfer process. Our calculations indicate that the CB 
disk can significantly enhance the mass transfer rates, especially for systems with low-mass 
(< 2M0) donor stars, to trigger SNe la explosions. In particular, these progenitor systems 
are consistent with the time delay of ~ 1 — 3 Gyr between the formation of the progenitors 
and the SNe la. This scenario could also explain the existence of the peculiar SSS contain- 
ing rapidly accreting white dwarf and very low-mass donor star like IE 0035.4—7230 (e.g. 


Fig. 3. — Distribution of the progenitor systems of SNe la in the Md,i — -Porb,i diagram. The 
bias and pane shading denote the distribution area of WD binaries with a WD of initial 
mass 1.2Mq and O.SMq, respectively. 




3.8 3.7 


Fig. 4. — Distribution of the donor stars in the HR diagram when and after SNe la explosions 
occur. The triangles and circles denote the donor stars accompanied by an initial WD of 
1.2Mq and O.SM©, while the sohd and open signs represent the cases of when and after SNe 
la explosions occur, respectively. 

- 11 - 

Taam fc Spruitll200lh . 

Obviously there exist many uncertainties in the CB disk-driven mass accretion onto 
WDs in this work. First, the existence of the CB disk in supersoft X-ray bi naries needs to 

be confirmed or disp roved by future infrared observations (IDubus et aLll2004l ). as in GG Tau 

( jRoddier et aLlll996l ). Second, the calculated mass transfer processes depend sensitively on 
the adopted value of S, which is poorly known, and likely to change with time. This makes it 
difficult to estimate the contribution of the such binaries to SNe la. Third, we do not include 

exceed 1AM 

Howell et al. 


Uenishi et al. 


Yoon & Laneer 


progenitor scenario are more compatible with observations, we need to investigate carefully 
various mass transfer processes in WD binaries. 

This research was supported by Natural Science Foundation of China under grant num- 
ber 10573010, 10573009, and by the Graduate Scientific Research Foundation of Jiangsu 
Province, China. 


Barris, B. J., & Tonry, J. L. 2006, ApJ, 637, 427 
Belczynski, K., Bulik, T., & Ruiter, A. 2005, ApJ, 629, 915 

Branch, D., Livio, M., Yungelson, L. R., Boffi, F. R., & Baron, E. 1995, PASP, 107, 717 
Canal, R., Mendez, J., & Ruiz-Lapuente, P. 2001, ApJ, 550, L53 

Cannizzo, J. K. 1993, in Accretion Disks in Compact Stellar Systems, ed. J. C. Wheeler 
(Singapore: World ScientiDc), 6 

Chen, W.-C, Li, X.-D., & Qian, S.-B. 2006, ApJ, 649, 973 

Chen, W.-C, & Li, X.-D. 2006, MNRAS, 373, 305 

Dubus, G., Campbell, R., Kern, B., Taam, R. E., & Spruit, H. C. 2004, MNRAS, 349, 869 
Eggleton, P. P. 1971, MNRAS, 151, 351 
Eggleton, P. P. 1972, MNRAS, 156, 361 

- 12 - 

Forster, F., Wolf, C, Podsiadlowski, Ph., Han, Z. 2006, MNRAS, 368, 1893 
Gal- Yam, A. & Maoz, D. 2004, MNRAS, 347, 942 

Gansicke, B. T., van Teeseling, A., Beuermann, K., & de Martino, D. 1998, A&A, 333, 163 

Hachisu, 1., Kato, M., & Nomoto, K. 1996, ApJ, 470, L97 

Hachisu, I., Kato, M., Nomoto, K., & Umeda, H. 1999, ApJ, 519, 314 

Han, Z., Podsiadlowski, P., & Eggleton, P. P. 1994, MNRAS, 270, 121 

Han, Z., & Podsiadlowski, Ph. 2004, MNRAS, 350, 1301 

Hoyle, F., & Fowler, W. A. 1960, ApJ, 132, 565 

Howell, D. A. et al. 2006, Nature, 443, 308 

Hutchings, J. B. et al. 1001, A J, 122, 1572 

Iben, 1. Jr., & Tutukov, A. V. 1984, ApJS, 54, 335 

Kahabka, P. & van den Heuvel, E. P. J. 1997, ARA&A, 35, 69 

Kato, M., Saio, H., & Hachisu, I. 1989, ApJ, 470, L97 

Kovetz, A., & Prialnik, D. 1994, ApJ, 424, 319 

Kuduz, M., Reinsch, K., Beuermann, K. & Kube, J. 2002, in The Physics of Cataclysmic 
Variables and Related Objects, ASP Conference Proceedings (ed. B. T. Gansicke, K. 
Beuermann, and K. Reinsch, San Francisco: Astronomical Society of the Pacific), vol. 
261. p. 641 

Langer, N., Deutschmann, A., Wellstein, S., & Hoflich, P. 2000, A&A, 362, 1046 

Li, X. -D., & van den Heuvel, E. P. J. 1997, A&A, 322, L9 

Long, K. S., Helfand, A., & Grabelsky, D. A. 1981, ApJ, 248, 925 

Mannucci F., Delia Valle M., Panagia N., 2006, MNRAS, 370, 773 

Marietta, E., Burrows, D. J., & Fryxell, B. 2000, ApJS, 128, 615 

Nomoto, K. 1982a, ApJ, 253, 798 

Nomoto, K. 1982b, ApJ, 257, 780 


Nomoto, K., Iben, I. 1985, ApJ, 297, 531 
Perlmutter, S., et al. 1999, ApJ, 517, 565 

Pols, O., Tout, C. A., Eggleton, P. P., & Han, Z. 1995, MNRAS, 274, 964 
Rappaport, S., Di Stefano, R., Smith, J. D. 1994, ApJ, 426, 492 
Riess, A. G. et al. 1998, AJ, 116, 1009 
Riess, A. G. et al. 2004, ApJ, 607, 665 

Roddier, C, Roddier, F., Northcott, M. J., Graves, J. E., & Jim, K. 1996, ApJ, 463, 326 

Saio, H., Nomoto, K. 1985, A&A, 150, L21 

Shakura, N. I., & Sunyaev, R. A. 1973, A&A, 24, 337 

Spruit, H. C, & Taam, R. E. 2001, ApJ, 548, 900 

Strolger, L. -G., et al. 2004, ApJ, 613, 200 

Strolger, L.-G. et al., 2005, ApJ, 635, 1370 

Taam, R. E., & Spruit, H. C. 2001, ApJ, 561, 329 

Timmes, F. X., Woosley, S. E., & Taam, R. E. 1994, ApJ, 420, 348 

Uenishi, T., Nomoto, K., & Hachisu, I. 2003, ApJ, 595, 1094 

van den Heuvel, E.P.J. , & de Loore, C. 1973, A&A, 25, 387 

van den Hcuvcl, E. P. J., Bhattacharya, D., Nomoto, K., & Rappaport, S. A. 1992, A&A, 
262, 97 

van den Heuvel, E.P.J. 1994 in Interacting Binaries (Saas-Fee 22), Shore, S. N., et al., eds., 

van Teeseling, A., & King, A. R. 1998, A&A, 338, 957 
Webbink, R. F. 1984, ApJ, 277, 355 

Wheeler, J. C., lecar, M., & McKee, C. F. 1975, ApJ, 200, 145 
Woosley, S. E., & Weaver, T. A. 1986, ARA&A, 24, 205 
Yoon, S. -C., & Langer, N. 2005, A&A, 435, 967 

- 14- 

Yungelson, L. & Livio, M. 1998, ApJ, 497, 168 

This preprint was prepared with the A AS IM^jX macros v5.2.