Skip to main content
Internet Archive's 25th Anniversary Logo

Full text of ""Convergent observations" with the stereoscopic HEGRA CT system"

See other formats


"Convergent observations" with the 
stereoscopic HEGRA CT system 

Hubert Lampeitl and Werner Hofmann 
for the HEGRA Collaboration 


Q^ . Max-Planck-Institut fiir Kernphysik, P.O. Box 103980, D-69029 Heidelberg, Germany 

-(— > 


Abstract. Observations of air showers with the stereoscopic HEGRA I ACT system 
j^ , are usually carried out in a mode where all telescopes point in the same direction. 

Alternatively, one could take into account the finite distance to the shower maximum 
and orient the telescopes such that their optical axes intersect at the average height of 
the shower maximum. In this paper we show that this "convergent observation mode" 
is advantageous for the observation of extended sources and for surveys, based on a 
^^ • small data set taken with the HEGRA telescopes operated in this mode. 


0> . The HEGRA collaboration is operating a system of currently five imaging at- 



I ' at the Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos (ORM), at 2.2 km asl. The sys- 

^ ■ tem telescopes feature a mirror area of 8.5 m^ and a focal length of 5 m and are 

c/j ! equipped with 271-pixel photomultiplier cameras. Based on the multiple views ob- 

tained for each shower, the orientation of the shower axis in space as well as the 
location of the shower core can be determined. Compared to single lACTs, stereo- 
^ . scopic lACT systems provide superior angular resolution, energy resolution, and 

background rejection [1-3]. During typical observations with the HEGRA lACT 
system, the optical axes of all telescopes are parallel and either point directly to 
the source, or - in the so-called wobble mode - at a point displaced by ±0.5° in 
declination relative to the source. In the latter case, the rate in a region displaced 
by the same distance from the optical axis, but in the opposite direction, is used 
to estimate off-source background rates. 

With all telescopes pointing in exactly the same direction, both the operation of 
the system and the data analysis are simplified, but one may wonder if the detection 
characteristics could not be improved by canting the telescopes towards each other, 
such that their optical axes intersect roughly at the height of the shower maximum. 
Such an alignment of telescopes would guarantee that the most luminous region of 
an air shower is optimally viewed by all telescopes simultaneously. 

The two alternatives are shown in Fig. 1, which also serves to illustrate the trigger 



mospheric Cherenkov telescopes (lACTs) for the stereoscopic observation of VHE 
cosmic 7-rays [1] . The telescope system is located on the Canary Island La Palma, 



Light pool 

FIGURE 1. Illustration of the geometry with parallel (a) and canted (b) telescopes. The 
dashed lines show the optical axes of the telescopes. The "active area" indicates where the 
shower maximum can be observed in both telescopes. 

characteristics of lACT arrays. To first approximation, an individual lACT will 
trigger on an air shower if two conditions are fulfilled [4]: 

1. the telescope has to be located within the light pool of the shower, with its 
typical radius of about 120 m, and 

2. the shower maximum has to be within the field of view of the camera. 

For the HEGRA telescopes, with their 4.3° field of view, the latter condition implies 
that the shower maximum - at TeV energies typically located 6 km above the tele- 
scopes - should be within 225 m from the optical axis of the telescope. For showers 
propagating parallel to the optical axis, the second condition is automatically ful- 
filled, once a telescope is within the light pool of the air shower. The camera field 
of view adds an additional constraint only for showers at angles of more than 1° 
relative to the optical axis (at least as far as triggering is concerned - to avoid 
truncation of images, one may want to require in addition in the subsequent image 
analysis that the centroid of the image is at least 0.5° away from the edge of the field 
of view; this will still result in a field of view of about 175 m radius at the shower 
maximum). Therefore, canting of telescopes is most likely not an issue for studies 
of point sources near the center of the field of view; it may however be important 
for the observation of extended sources as well as for surveys of larger areas of the 
sky, where it is important to maximize sensitivity over a large solid angle. For two 
telescopes, the situation is relatively obvious from Fig. 1: for parallel pointing, the 
range of locations of the shower maximum, and hence the accessible solid angle, is 
much more restricted than for canted telescopes. For three or more telescopes, the 

conclusion depends on the locations of the telescopes and the trigger conditions; 
parallel pointing will reduce the solid angle for a coincidence of all A^ telescopes, 
but may increase the angle if only 2 out of A^ telescopes are required in the trigger 
and in the subsequent analysis. 

Estimates of detection rates were carried out for the actual geometry of the 
HEGRA lACT system, with telescopes located at three of the four corners of a 
square of about 100 m side length, and another telescope located at the center of 
the square (the remaining corner telescope had at that time - summer 1998 - an 
older camera and was not yet included in the lACT system). The rate estimates 
were based on the simplified model discussed above, assuming a radius of the light 
pool of about 120 m and a usable field of view (without edge distortion of the 
images) of 3.6°. Two cases were compared: 1) parallel optical axes of all telescopes, 
and 2) telescopes canted such that the axes intersect in a height of 6 km, with 
the nominal pointing of the lACT system defined as the pointing of the central 
telescope. The results - event rates for a given source flux and observation time 
as a function of the distance of the source from the optical axis of the central 
telescope - are shown in Fig. 2(a)-(d). The simulations indicate almost identical 
total detection rates for the two pointing modes (Fig. 2(a)). However, for sources 
more than 0.5° from the optical axis of the system, the "convergent observation 
mode" provides a significantly larger fraction of four-telescope events (Fig. 2(d)). 
Since both the angular resolution and the cosmic-ray rejection improve with the 
number of triggered telescopes, the convergent mode is clearly favorable. 

To verify these model predictions experimentally, three hours of observations of 
the Crab nebula were performed with canted telescopes. The cosmic-ray back- 
ground provides a uniform flux of particles and allows to study detection rates as 
a function of the distance to the optical axis of the lACT system. At last qual- 
itatively, these characteristics should be similar for hadronic showers and for the 
more interesting 7-ray induced showers. Limited observation time and low counting 
rate prevented us from scanning the field of view using the Crab nebula as a 7-ray 

Fig. 3 illustrates the effect of the canting: the positions of the images in the 
different cameras coincide, whereas for the parallel pointing mode they are dis- 
placed by about 6 ~ d/h ^ 1° along the direction connecting the locations of the 
telescopes. Here, d is the spacing of the telescopes and h the height of the shower 
maximum. As a consequence, in convergent mode it is unlikely that images in some 
of the telescopes are truncated; either all telescopes have well-contained images, or 
all images suffer from edge problems. 

Due to slight differences in the weather conditions, the telescopes trigger rates 
varied somewhat between the observations taken in convergent tracking mode, and 
the reference data set. Since the pointing mode may influence the trigger rates, 
one cannot simply normalize the data sets on the basis of the raw trigger rates. To 
derive the correct normalization factor, the fleld of view in convergent mode was 
artiflcially truncated to 2.4° diameter, and in the reference data set - with parallel 
pointing - the convergent pointing was mocked up by selecting in software a 2.4° 

v^ 8000 
I 6000 F 
® 4000 

FIGURE 2. Left: simple geometrical model for the number of detected showers as a function 
of the angle between the shower axis and the axis of the telescope system, for parallel axes of the 
telescopes (dashed line) and for canted telescopes (full line), (a) Total rate, (b) 2-telescope events, 
(c) 3-telescope events, (d) 4-telescope events. Right: experimental detection rates for cosmic-ray 
showers, for all events (e), 2-telescope events (f), 3-telescope events (g) and 4-telescope events 
(h), for parallel (points) and canted alignment of axes (triangles). 

field of view sliifted by tlie canting angle. After these software trigger cuts, the 
detection rates can be compared, resulting in a 24 ± 2% correction. 

The corrected cosmic-ray detection rates as a function of the angle relative to the 
system axis are shown in Fig. 2(e) for the total rate, and separately for 2-telescope 
(f), 3-telescope (g), and 4-telescope events (h). Here, only images within the central 
3.6° of the field of view were accepted, to exclude truncated images. The observed 
pattern matches that predicted by the simple model: very similar total rates, but a 
clear enhancement of the 4-telescope rate at larger angles in case of the convergent 
pointing mode, at the expense of 2 and 3-telescope events. For the 4-telescope 
events, the diameter of the effective field of view is increased by about 0.8°. 

During the data taking in convergent mode, the Crab nebula was positioned 
0.5° off the system optical axis. Under these conditions, one would not expect any 




dx (deg) 

FIGURE 3. Difference in the centroid positions of images in two cameras for parallel (a) and 
convergent observations (b). The camera coordinate systems are rotated in a way that the x-axis 
points along the line connecting the telescopes. 

difference in detection rates between the two modes, and indeed the Crab signals 
in the two modes are well consistent within the statistical errors of about 20%. 

In summary, for stereoscopic lACT systems, the convergent tracking mode - 
canting the telescopes towards each other such that their optical axes intersect at 
the height of the shower maximum - improves the detection capabilities in partic- 
ular for sources near the edge of the field of view, and is advised for observations 
of extended sources and for surveys. 

Acknowledgments. The support of the German Ministry for Research and 
Technology BMBF and of the Spanish Research Council CYCIT is gratefully ac- 
knowledged. We thank the Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias for the use of the 
site and for providing excellent working conditions. We gratefully acknowledge the 
technical support staff of Heidelberg, Kiel, Munich, and Yerevan. 


1. A. Daum et al., Astroparticle Phys. 8 (1997) 1. 

2. N. Bulian et al., Astropart. Phys. 8 (1998) 223. 

3. F.A. Aharonian et al., Astron. Astrophys. 342 (1999) 69. 

4. C. Kohler et al., Astroparticles Physics 6 (1996) 77.